A few years after publishers fell in and out of love with games, they are toying around with them again.
In the past couple months, Hearst Digital has begun producing branded puzzle games and quizzes for MSN; both Mic and the Washington Post have begun experimenting with non-branded game bots on platforms like Kik and Facebook Messenger, respectively; The Outline, Josh Topolsky’s venture-backed “New Yorker for millennials,” rolled out a game within a week of going live, called “Musk Lander”; meanwhile, in print media, the New York Times announced it would publish a special Puzzles section in the Dec. 18 edition of its newspaper.
These steps haven’t produced any smash hits for publishers yet, or if they have, they’re keeping it to themselves: Hearst did not respond to requests for comment about its games, and both WaPo and Mic declined to share numbers. But with more publishers looking for ways to foster loyalty among readers (and draw them to their owned and operated sites on a regular basis), publishers are giving games another go.
“Our hypothesis has been that interactive elements lead people down a path toward loyalty,” said Greg Barber, the Washington Post’s director of digital news products. “We’re still a ways out from being able to prove that, but that’s what we’re trying to get to.”
Games like crossword puzzles, word jumbles and sudokus have been fixtures in newspapers and magazines for decades. And plenty of publishers, particularly newspapers, continue to drive small, but meaningful chunks of digital revenue from them. The New York Times, for example, earned $2.4 million in the third quarter of 2016 from crossword app revenues. Other publishers, including USA Today and The Los Angeles Times, have come to depend on stable, healthy flows of ad revenue from readers who come by regularly to play everything from crosswords to matching games.
Arkadium, a company that provides games for all of the above publishers, among others, claims the average session on one of its partner sites lasts more than 15 minutes, and during that time they see more than three more ads than that site’s average visitor would.
“With most publishers, we’re sub-5 percent [of the total readership],” said Jessica Rovello Arkadium co-founder. “But we’re much more of an outsized revenue driver.”
But about five years ago, publishers began toying around with the idea of using games as a storytelling tool, too. Wired launched games designed to give people a sense of everything from pandemics to the economics of Somali pirates; The Huffington Post launched a Mortal Kombat-styled game oriented around the 2012 presidential debates.
Indeed, the just-concluded election seemed to get publishers back into the gaming mood. The New York Times published an Everyday Arcade game called “The Voter Suppression Trail”; The Washington Post launched a mobile game called “Floppy Candidate”; Wonkette worked with the UK-based game developer Auroch Digital on “Elections of US America Election: The Card Game,” a turn-based card game it funded on Kickstarter.
These all grabbed headlines. But they never spurred publications to invest more meaningfully in them. “This stuff is made to be novel rather than to do journalism,” said Ian Bogost, a distinguished chair of media studies at Georgia Tech and the author of “Newsgames.” “[Those games] never rose to the level of becoming speech.”
They also didn’t do much in the way of making money. While BuzzFeed managed to turn quizzes into a moneymaker – they now account for 15 percent of that site’s branded posts, and that number’s going up, according to Summer Anne Burton, an executive creative director there – lots of publishers are reluctant to put substantial resources behind things that don’t make money.
“I don’t want to boil it down to, ‘People don’t like to take risks,’” said Peter Willington, a producer at Auroch Digital. “But I do think with media brands in general, there is a reluctance to try something new when the old is known to provide results.”
But with more and more publishers focused on getting people off of platforms like Facebook and Snapchat, games might be worth a go. The only way to find out, though, will involve committing to them.
“If you published a newspaper [only] once, it would be a curiosity,” Bogost said. “If you do it every day, it becomes an institution.”
How digital news publishers will compete for political ad dollars in this year’s U.S. midterm elections
The midterms are expected to draw a historic amount of political ad spend. How will publishers compete for those dollars?
Ocean Media’s Jay Langan on how data fueled this independent agency’s long-term strategy
Over the last two decades, Ocean Media has emerged as one of the largest data-driven firms helping transform popular brands like Mint Mobile and Rakuten into household names.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: Advertising and commerce ebb while subscriptions flow in publisher’s Q2 earnings reports
In this week's Media Briefing, media editor Kayleigh Barber analyzes the latest quarterly earnings reports from BuzzFeed, IAC's Dotdash Meredith, News Corp's Dow Jones, Gannett and The New York Times.
SponsoredHow brands are activating Gen Z and millennial TikTok audiences
Roland Hamilton, senior vice president of global licensing, Trusted Media Brands Although TikTok is widely considered a Gen Z platform, the video-sharing app also boasts a high number of millennial users. With more than 100 million active users in the U.S. alone, 32% of TikTok’s global audience is between the ages of 25–34. This large […]
Can Niche build the next decentralized social platform? Here’s why it matters
Niche is a decentralized online marketplace and social networking platform rolled into one. Unlike other social apps, it doesn't carry ads and it doesn't harvest user data.
Member ExclusiveDigiday+ Research deep dive: YouTube investments pay off for publishers’ brands, revenues
In this final installment of Digiday+ Research's deep dive into how publishers are using social media platforms, we're covering how publishers are investing time and money on YouTube -- and how that's translating to their revenues and brands.