Safari’s new private browsing mode provides a new path around publisher paywalls
Publishers have discovered a new, Apple-shaped hole in their metered paywalls.
The most recent version of Apple’s Safari browser, which began rolling out to users in late September, prevents sites from detecting when Safari visitors have the browser’s private browsing mode enabled. Private browsing, like incognito mode, temporarily prevents publishers from reading or writing cookies to a phone or computer, which makes it impossible for a paywall to detect how much content a reader has consumed, thereby rendering the meter useless.
The change also evades the countermeasures many news publishers deployed in an attempt to stop visitors using incognito mode. For example, an internet user who tries to read a story on The Boston Globe’s website using Chrome’s incognito mode will be blocked by a window demanding that visitors register or turn the mode off.
But a visitor using the most recent version of Safari in private browsing mode doesn’t get that same message and can read a limitless amount of content on the Globe’s site, simply by opening stories in new private tabs each time.
Far fewer Americans browse the internet using Safari than Google’s Chrome browser. Safari claims 9% of the U.S. desktop browser market share, according to Statcounter. (The picture is different on mobile devices: Safari claimed 53% of mobile browser market share in the U.S. in September, also according to Statcounter; Chrome accounted for 40% that same month).
But Safari users, who are overwhelmingly Apple device owners, are disproportionately valuable because they tend to be more affluent, and they tend to pay for news; Apple users tend to over-index as news subscribers, said Pete Doucette, managing director in the telecoms, media and technology practice at FTI Consulting, and for many news publishers, they tend to represent a majority of subscribers.
The change is recent enough that few publishers have determined the change is negatively affecting their businesses. An executive at one news publisher that operates a metered paywall noted that subscription sales driven by users in private mode was “slightly softer” this weekend, but the overall numbers were too low to form any conclusions.
More broadly, Safari’s update adds one more thing to a long to-do list for subscription-focused publishers, who already have a tough time figuring out how to convince readers to pay for subscriptions. “This will lead to a hard paywall for all readers and also make it more difficult to monetize content,” said Danielle Coffey, svp of strategic initiatives at the News Media Alliance. “While we’re interested in protecting our readers’ privacy, we still need a return on our investments to sustain quality journalism.”
Browser changes have been giving publishers headaches all year, on both the advertising and subscription fronts. In late July, a change Google made to Chrome forced publishers to find a new way to detect whether people were browsing the site in incognito mode, despite months of complaints and protests publishers made with Google. Anti-tracking changes made by Firefox have dropped the value of publisher ad inventory viewed in those browsers by more than 15% in countries such as Germany.
In response, publishers have become newly focused on cutting down the number of anonymous readers they have, turning to registration walls, among other things.
Those efforts may need to be accelerated, because observers expect that Safari will not be the last browser to make this kind of move, with web browsers continuing to focus on privacy to stay in the good graces of consumers and regulators.
“I would expect to see something like this come from Firefox and Opera soon,” said Dael Jackson, director of engagement products at Naviga, a paywall vendor. “Privacy is becoming a big focus for browsers, and they’re definitely going to be persistent in maintaining that privacy.”
‘We’re netting out with higher revenue’: Publishers reaping the benefits of Snapchat’s strong second half
With CPMs up as much as 20% year over year in the fourth quarter, many Discover publishers are bullish on the upstart platform for next year.
How Cosmo is building brand affinity with younger audiences through its focus on commerce
Cosmopolitan's focus on e-commerce through a line of branded wines and its own shopping holiday has led to a 254% increase in product sales.
‘Profitability in the back half of next year’: BuzzFeed CEO Jonah Peretti (and Verizon Media CEO Guru Gowrappan) on their big merger
A special Digiday podcast episode features Interviews with BuzzFeed CEO Jonah Peretti and Verizon Media CEO Guru Gowrappan.
SponsoredPublishers will lead the charge as cookie-less advertising becomes the norm
Steve Wing, managing director, EMEA, Magnite As the advertising industry moves closer to a cookieless world — one in which browserless environments including connected TV (CTV) and mobile in-app are an increasingly large part of ad budgets — publishers will have an increasingly important role in developing the future of identity. Segment creation and identity […]
‘People have had permission to experiment’: Pandemic expedites rethink on 9-to-5 work structures
Starting out as a short-term fix to weather the coronavirus storm, employers are seeing work hours outside the traditional 9-to-5 week as a new normal.
‘A digital Madison Square Garden’: How Complex reimagined the sponsorship opportunities for ComplexLand
The online event, which will combine music, conversation, gaming and shopping in an online world, will have 60 sponsors.