Join us Dec. 1-3 in Nashville for the Digiday Programmatic Marketing Summit
FroYo monger 16 Handles was on Snapchat back when most adults assumed it was for sexting.
Back in 2013, 16 Handles asked Snapchat users to snap them a photo of them tasting its yogurt in exchange for a coupon. (Users had to open the snap at the register since it would disappear in 10 seconds.) The effort was heralded as the first brand to use the app.
The frozen yogurt chain is whittling down the number of social platforms it uses in a bid to focus on what really works, and Lara Nicotra, marketing manager is calling Snapchat her “2016 thing.”
It makes sense: The brand’s main focus is millennial females, between the ages of 18 and 34, and mostly in an urban demographic. (It’s not kids, although the brand says it doesn’t really market to them but also doesn’t really exclude them.) That’s explains suggestive ad copy, like “Let’s spoon,” its tagline for its February fro-yo flavor of the month.

16 Handles operates with a small team and on a small budget, which is what makes its approach to social relatively unique. The brand starts each day with a meeting where Nicotra’s team is asked by founder Solomon Choi to brush up on “industry stuff.” That means, for example, finding out about new social platforms or new features on older ones. “We try to have this sense of curiosity” said Nicotra.
But curiosity can also be a problem: For example, 16 Handles was one of the first brands to get onto Kik in late 2014 in a bid to reach teen customers where they were. The brand generated 27,000 interactions with a small amount of paid media behind it in the first few days, but then the app waned — and with it, the brand’s traction. “That was one of our possible failures,” admits Nicotra.
This year, the brand plans to focus on Snapchat Stories — longer Snapchats that stick around for 24 hours — that will work hand-in-hand with the company’s refurbished content calendar. “In the past, it was just ‘let’s give people cool access to our brand’,” said Nicotra. “Now, it’s a commitment.”
The brand will peg stories to certain times of the day, such as that post-snack 3 p.m. sugar rush. And Nicotra wants to try and focus Snapstories on content that will last longer and “talk to” what’s happening in-store. “It’s a full time job.”
Nicotra declined to disclose how many followers the brand has on Snapchat, but as it focuses on the platform, she said, 16 Handles has decided to stop using other platforms, including Tumblr and Pinterest. Her interest in using Twitter as a paid platform has also waned. Like other brands, Nicotra said she isn’t seeing the returns, even though Twitter says it has many programs for brands with brick-and-mortar retail presences.
“We’ve seen a big dropoff on Twitter,” she said. Instagram, understandably, still works, since pictures of pretty frozen yogurt do well for its target demographic. The brand has seen a 36 percent increase in Instagram followers to 15,000 in the last year.
More in Marketing
Substack job listing hints at a bigger advertising push in 2027
A new product manager role will explore ad-related monetization, suggesting the platform could make ads a bigger part of its business.
Deloitte Digital takes the holdco operating system pitch straight to the CEO
CEOs have never cared much for holdcos. Enterprise solutions, on the other hand, get a meeting.
D+ Research: Marketers express revenue optimism for 2026 holiday season despite economic pressures
Marketers expect their 2026 holiday revenue to increase 1% to 31% or more in comparison to their 2025 holiday revenue.