‘There’s no need to pay for a trading desk’: Confessions of a marketer taking programmatic in-house
For all the talk of advertisers buying their own programmatic ads, there are few examples of it done well. In the latest installment of our anonymous Confessions series, in which we exchange anonymity for honesty, we talked to a marketer who overcame a mix of logistical and political pitfalls so that their team, rather than their media agency, could buy programmatic ads. While there were several reasons for doing so, the source said one benefit rose above the rest — cost savings.
Excerpts lightly edited for clarity and flow.
How did the internal programmatic team save you money?
When compared anecdotally in conversation with other marketers or in reference to research from ISBA, the percentage of our media budget that we spent on media instead of fees compared to the market was highly advantageous. My costs were typically in the 20 percent area as a percentage of media budget. That included my technology, which was primarily DoubleClick Bid Manager and DoubleClick Campaign Manager. No need to pay for a trading desk plus a core agency team. That number did not include staff costs, but again we always saw that as a saving as we were not paying for full-time-employee rates with an agency multiplier on top.
Aside from cost savings we also just spent more time making more optimizations than we could have with an agency. That led to us growing our budget by a factor of 5 between 2015 and 2016.
Why were you so against agencies helping you?
I worked at a company that didn’t like to pay third-party fees if it didn’t have to. We were encouraged to do as much as we could ourselves. The only thing the media agency employed by the marketing team did was buy TV. That didn’t stop the agency trying to take the programmatic buying away from us — programmatic was seen as a pot of gold to our agency because my team had a multi-million pound budget for it.
Was there agency pushback?
Initially, the agency tried to discourage us from taking programmatic in-house and on one occasion, incorrectly I might add, accused my team of deep ignorance before telling us they wouldn’t help. Each year the traders from the agency would descend on us to try and talk us around to giving them control over our ad tech stack. I felt the agencies were complicit in how much was undisclosed by the companies on the supply-side of the programmatic chain.
‘Becoming a vertical’: How Complex’s research arm turned into a 7-figure revenue stream
Last year, Complex Collective doubled its number of clients from six to 12 brands, including Banana Republic, the CDC and The Advisory Council.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: Publishers eye opportunity to close the loop with retailers
This week’s Media Briefing looks at how publishers are discussing content syndication opportunities with retailers that could help to address advertisers’ retail media pain points.
Microsoft’s ad revenue hit $10B, and it’s investing — is it a sleeping giant about to wake?
Microsoft's ad revenues hit $10 billion in the same year it spent big on ad tech. What exactly does it have in store for Xandr?
SponsoredHow online commerce platforms can deliver safer shopping experiences
Marni Levine, vice president, commerce operations, Meta In the wake of the pandemic, commerce underwent a rapid shift online, exponentially accelerating and forcing businesses of all sizes to adapt. Now moving into 2022, these trends will only continue as people have grown accustomed to shopping online more for all their needs. According to a PwC […]
Why publishers are using hoteling software to manage their hybrid workforces
Publishers like Quartz and BuzzFeed are using hoteling software to manage employees who are coming in to work from the office.
The Rundown: Horizon Media’s latest report IDs trends brands need to embrace in 2022
Coining a new term or two along the way, Horizon Media's trends report touches on areas such as digital privacy, contactless living, environmental goals, and the need for downtime.