By now, most publishers have gotten over their hang ups about programmatic selling and made the tech core to their revenue operations. But few have gone as far as Bauer Xcel Media, the U.S. digital offshoot of European magazine giant Bauer Media, which has ditched its direct sales force in favor of a “100 percent programmatic” approach.
The company, which owns entertainment and teen magazines such as InTouch Weekly and J-14, has slowly expanded its business in the U.S. over the past two years. To get there, the company spent much of 2014 building its five-person national sales team, which was charged with securing big deals with buyers. That changed this July, when the company shifted gears and replaced those direct sellers with a combination of third-party partners and a two-person ad operations team.
The rationale for the shift: While an internal sales team might help Bauer reach bigger brands, programmatic was actually making the company more money. Bauer Media, which comScore says gets 9 million monthly uniques, wasn’t turning many heads at media buying agencies, making it hard to justify the cost of a pricy sales team, according to Bauer Xcel Media president Christian Baesler.
“When we looked at the net costs of the direct sales effort and the speed of building it up, it made having that team less favorable for us than working through programmatic channels,” he said.
The idea that programmatic selling could entirely replace the wine-and-dine world of sales might seem unlikely to many publishers, which have until very recently seen programmatic as the realm of cheap, unsold inventory. But the efficiencies of programmatic have been hard for others ignore. In January, AOL fired 150 employees, largely from its sales team, as it continued its investment in programmatic tech. (A more cynical take: whacking dozens of expensive sales people helped sweeten the deal for Verizon, which bought AOL only four months later.)
But while Bauer might be seeing some early success with its programmatic-only approach, going salesperson-free is a route few publishers are likely to take. “The trend is to actually have programmatic practices influence the sales operation more, not less,” said Matt Prohaska, CEO of Prohaska Consulting, which helps publishers develop their programmatic operations. “Other companies have tried this and found out that you absolutely still need a couple of humans here and there.”
One of those companies is ad network Technorati, which in 2013 decided to sunset its custom content division and train its sales force on the ins and outs of programmatic selling. Some made the transition; others did not. The takeaway, according to Technorati CEO Shani Higgins: Laying off a sales team won’t make a publisher fully programmatic overnight.
“If you believe that you can just reduce your sales force and rely on ad operations team and the whole operation will go into autopilot, you’re going to be very surprised,” she said. “You don’t just get rid of people and suddenly become more efficient.”
More in Media
OpenAI, The New York Times debate copyright infringement of AI tech companies in first trial arguments
The copyright infringement trial between The New York Times and OpenAI kicked off in a federal court hearing on Tuesday. Here’s what both parties argued.
Financial Times, MiQ and Uber Advertising are 2024 Digiday Awards Europe finalists
This year, the companies driving innovation in Europe focused on omnichannel strategies, including leaning on first-party data and AI-driven insights to improve targeting and audience engagement. The Digiday Awards Europe finalists also share a common theme of elevating user experiences to deliver more impactful technology and campaigns. For instance, the Financial Times is a nominee […]
Digiday+ Research: More than half of publishers reported revenue increases in 2024
Publishers said revenues were up last year and media companies had a successful 2024 — but that success didn’t extend to the media industry as a whole.