As protests escalate, advertisers and media owners face a fresh crisis
U.S. advertisers and publishers had only just started to look beyond coronavirus triage mode when another crisis came hurtling into view.
The death of George Floyd, an unarmed black man who died late last month after being arrested by a white police officer, has sparked protests across the country, many of which have flared into violence between police and demonstrators. Several cities have imposed curfews and President Trump has threatened to deploy the military to suppress disorder. Conversations about police violence and racial injustice have sparked worldwide.
The fast-moving and highly fractious situation has again thrown advertiser and publishers into a state of uncertainty and fear. For many marketers, the instinct is again to go quiet and reassess how the situation unfolds, much as the approach was in the first month of coronavirus.
“Nobody was imagining we would have to be replanning for these sorts of circumstances yet again,” said Barry Lowenthal, chief executive of media agency The Media Kitchen.
The range of curfews across the country and instances of vandalism throw in other practical media planning and optimization dilemmas around whether advertising is appropriate in locations where stores aren’t open or where offering food delivery, for example, could put staff in danger.
“This is different than Covid-19 where the advice to clients was closer to ‘Keep calm and carry on’ — right now, there are bigger and deeper societal issues to address when the country is in trauma,” said Joshua Lowcock, chief digital and global brand safety officer at UM.
“Be empathetic” is the key piece of advice Lowcock is giving to clients that are still in-market. “And don’t be in-market if it puts your team members or the public at risk,” he added.
For news publishers, the latest unrest comes at an already painful time. The coronavirus crisis has triggered mass layoffs, furloughs and closures of titles following a major decline in the ad market and the expectation of a prolonged economic downturn. And while traffic to news sites soared during the first few weeks of the pandemic, some advertisers that were still spending during the period sought to actively avoid coronavirus content, or even bad news.
The current news cycle presents many keywords and categories — such as “death” and violence” — nervous advertisers might look to avoid. From May 29 through June 1, the number of pages flagged as “negative news” on contextual targeting platform Peer 39’s network was 12.9% of the overall volume, up from 10.7% in the two weeks prior to Floyd’s death. The Peer 39 negative news category includes content about crime, accidents, death, disasters, terror and war.
Daniel Avital, chief strategy officer at Cheq, a tech vendor that offers a brand safety tool that analyzes the context of the content on a page rather than keywords, said 90% of clients had requested some form of tightening of restrictions for stories related to the U.S. protests. The 10% that hadn’t requested to be excluded, had largely decided to proactively support news organizations as part of their brand safety policies, said Avital.
An early poll of GroupM clients found that close to 60% of those surveyed had actively chosen not to blanket-block news related to the unrest, but some are in discussions about whether to pause campaigns, said John Montgomery, the agency’s executive vice president of global brand safety. A source at one large U.S. news publisher said they had yet to see a major dip in advertising yield related to the current news cycle.
Even still, the possibility that premium news organizations might be penalized in covering another era defining — but ultimately negative — story in the last few days could present another major blow. In the last few days, dozens of reporters and photographers have been attacked or arrested while covering the demonstrations, according to the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker. Meanwhile, President Trump has continued to use his Twitter account to deride the press.
Tracy De Groose, executive chair of U.K. news media trade group Newsworks, said the fallout from and situation leading to Floyd’s death marks an incredibly important story that will broaden and continue to run.
“Of course there are genuine sensitivities around the context of advertising placement but I would encourage advertisers and agencies to regularly check their approach, and block lists, to ensure they are not commercially censoring the free flow of journalism around this incredibly important and evolving issue,” said De Groose.
For now, many marketers are turning to messages of support and solidarity on social media. Yet the parade of brands posting similarly worded messages against black backgrounds is somewhat similar to the initial “in these uncertain times” coronavirus response, which was quickly lampooned for its sameness and reliance on platitudes rather than pledging helpful action or financial support.
“Brands just need to do better,” said Christopher Kenna, CEO of diversity focused media network Brand Advance. “There’s no right or wrong answer [in engaging with the current situation] as long as you can say hand on heart that ‘this is authentic for us’ and everything you do around that feeds into that authenticity.”
Pinterest testing new co-sold, revenue-share ad model for publishers with Tastemade
Currently in an experimental phase, Tastemade is the first publisher to sign on and the brand that is funding this ad experiment is corn chip snack Fritos.
As publishers clean up automated supply chains, education-title Chegg cut ad resellers and saw no negative impact on revenue
"We were told as publishers that resellers were so important, but no [publisher] has communicated to me they removed resellers and lost X% lift."
Member ExclusiveThe Facebook ad boycott could help publishers swing the pendulum back to context
Publishers have a golden opportunity to shift thinking around the role context, broadly defined, should play in advertising.
SponsoredFour ways to adapt to the changing publisher ecosystem in 2020
By Neal Sinno, general manager Americas at GeoEdge For marketers, 2020 started out with so much promise — but this changed rapidly as the industry faced a global epidemic head-on. Not only did our own daily routines come to a screeching halt, for many of us our professional lives did as well. Almost as quickly […]
Patagonia: Boycotting Facebook ads will lead to an ‘even more thoughtful approach’ to its ad buying
Patagonia has pulled all paid ads from Facebook and Instagram until at least the end of July. The boycott will extend if the advertiser has seen three specific changes to how the social network handles hate speech.
How Substack has spawned a new class of newsletter entrepreneurs
As the media ecosystem contracts amid coronavirus, Substack has been thrust into an uncomfortable role — that of a savior.