The biggest winners in the protracted end of granular tracking in Google’s Chrome browser: procrastinators.
Barely a week has passed since the announcement that the third-party cookie’s execution has been stayed further and there’s already evidence that ad executives are using it as an excuse to slow down post-cookie preparation plans.
In fairness, it’s sort of understandable. The further away a problem is, the less inclined someone is to tackle it — least of all marketers. Simply put, extended deadlines are an anathema to urgency, as the discourse over Google’s decision makes clear.
“We have seen examples of this in some conversations, where the emphasis has shifted back to ‘OK let’s see what more we can do to leverage data whilst we still have it’ and less on ‘how are we going to adapt to less data in the future,'” said Dan Larden, head of U.K. at digital media consultancy TPA. “Doing both of these things are very sensible approaches, but if it is a question of resource and you know the former has a time limit, you can understand why that may get prioritized in the short term on the demand side.”
The thinking that it’s better to lean on third-party cookies while they’re still around than act like they don’t exist seems to be the conventional wisdom around the industry. That definitely was the mindset among marketers when Google gave third-party cookies a pass last year, and it’s the same this time around. No surprise there. Not because it’s the smart play — clearly, the jury is still out on that. Rather, replacing third-party cookies is the marketer’s equivalent of going to the doctor — they will put off doing it until they can’t any longer.
A macroeconomic crisis only strengthens that resolve. It’s little wonder when there are so many things to consider about alternatives to third-party cookies, from the type of audience segmentation required to defining new reach and frequency standards — and that’s just the basics.
“Right now I think any serious ad tech vendor will move ahead with their plans, their survival still depends on it, but I’m a bit worried about how some advertisers will worry less about the cookie going away,” said the digital lead at a publisher in Europe who spoke to Digiday on condition of anonymity because they’re not authorized to talk to Digiday. “iOS is already more than half their reach in many markets so they should be exploring solutions and partnerships already, but with the timeline now extending beyond the average tenure of a CMO I’m not so sure we will see that sense of urgency.”
If this holds true, then progress in the search for viable alternatives to third-party cookies could be slow. Support — and more importantly knowledge — for some of these alternatives from marketers is already limited at best.
Seller-defined audiences are a case in point: Publishers want to test more of them. Marketers aren’t so sure. Worse still, the extension seems to have come at the worst possible time. Before Google surprised absolutely no one with the delay, momentum behind SDAs was building — albeit slowly. There were small tests being done and the early feedback was good. In fact, it looked like more media dollars were going to be committed to bigger tests. Google’s delay hasn’t necessarily changed that, but it hasn’t exactly firmed it up either.
“There’s a lack of commercial incentive to stop using data currencies that are going to be deprecated in the future,” said Benjamin Dick, senior director of product at IAB Tech Lab. “So we’re relying on long term decision making which is not something our industry has proven to be good at. Nonetheless the reaction we’ve had from the market to SDAs has been largely positive.”
To be clear, the lack of urgency isn’t isolated to marketers. It permeates throughout the ad industry. That’s clear in how many emerging solutions there are that still appear to at least be reliant on third-party cookies. It’s almost as if they’re banking on the proverbial can being kicked further down the road.
“I’m also seeing new ad networks springing up with innovative proprietary solutions that are essentially still reliant on cookies and don’t seem to have another solution,” said Nick Swimer, partner at law firm Reed Smith. “I’m just doing a deal with a large publisher who is engaging a big ad network that’s built this technology that’s all based on cookies rather than anything designed to future proof against the demise of them.”
How GAMURS shows the esports journalism industry’s struggle to overcome low freelance rates
Former staff members told Digiday that higher-ups routinely ignored their requests to raise freelance rates, and at times even increased freelancers’ workload without any consideration of increased wages.
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters partners with Martha Stewart to retool its social media strategy
In order to get the retain their current consumers while also reaching new, younger consumers, Green Mountain Coffee Roasters has worked to create more easily digestible content.
How Estonia adjusted its national branding strategy in response to the war in Ukraine
Following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Brand Estonia has officially added a fourth pillar to its national brand: the country’s embrace of democratic values. The purpose of the added messagin
SponsoredHow marketers are tailoring data-driven creative to engage audiences on CTV
Gabriela Maestre, vice president of creative solutions, Tremor International As the end of the year approaches and marketing teams look to finalize their 2023 budgets, many are wondering how to ensure their ads are set up for success in the months ahead, appealing to unique audiences whose media consumption habits continue to evolve. Advances in […]
Surging photo-sharing app BeReal has brands like Chipotle, e.l.f. Cosmetics rushing to understand platform’s appeal with Gen Z
As social media newcomer BeReal gains traction, marketers start discussions about where and if brands belong on BeReal.
The Rundown: Meta to put new ads all over Facebook and Instagram, including on user profiles
Meta is launching new ad formats this quarter, which are hoping to capitalize off of readers' appetite for discovery.