Digiday Research: Third-party data is a big problem in digital ad campaigns
At the Digiday Hot Topic UK: Data-Driven Publishing event last November in London, we sat down with over 20 advertising executives from major companies to better understand major challenges with using data in digital advertising. Check out our earlier research on brands’ plans to move marketing efforts in-house in 2018 here. Learn more about our upcoming events here.
- Thirty percent of respondents said unreliable third-party data was the biggest challenge when using data in digital campaigns.
- Eighty-two percent believe that third-party data is unreliable.
Unilever CMO Keith Weed urged the advertising world to address the murkiness and inefficiencies of the digital supply chain in his keynote address on Feb. 12 at the IAB Annual Leadership Meeting. In a conversation with Digiday, he emphasized what he calls the “three V’s“: viewability, third-party verification and value. While Weed raises important issues facing the industry, he neglects long-standing issues contributing to the “swamp” in which marketers often find themselves. According to a Digiday survey on the challenges with using data in digital campaigns, respondents said they have the most trouble with creating reliable audience segments and securing dependable third-party data.
Issues with third-party data and segmenting audience information have plagued digital advertising since its inception. Earlier Digiday research found that 8 in 10 advertisers don’t believe third-party data is reliable, and for good reason.
Major data management platform Lotame recently purged over 400 million profiles from its data pools after realizing they were bots and not real humans. At a more basic level, even binary gender data could be wrong. For example, a study by ChoiceStream found that about a third of the time, two third-party data providers disagreed about a user’s gender.
Marketers consistently view location data, an often employed type of third-party data, with skepticism. Long promised as a meaningful way to better target consumers, 94 percent of marketers in a Verve study reported struggling with location data, including its accuracy.
Publishers inadvertently contribute to the problem of unreliable third-party data. Much of a publisher’s audience data is leaked via programmatic exchanges to media buyers, who then merge it with their own third-party data to create cheaper lookalike audiences. This data, while less costly, is less precise than a publisher’s first-party data, further diluting the data available to advertisers.
Don’t expect third-party data to be cleaned up anytime soon. Because DMPs and their clients are incentivized to chase scale, they are often willing to accept a degree of data inaccuracy in exchange for being able to reach a larger audience. Now that Facebook is reducing the reach of brands and publishers on its platform, advertisers desperate for the scale and sophistication Facebook provided could turn to third-party data. Without Facebook’s organic reach, advertisers willing to increase their paid ad campaigns might tolerate the inadequacies of third-party data to maintain a presence with consumers.
Why a CBD brand is experimenting with OOH advertising to counter e-commerce buzzkills
As the digital marketing landscape continues to be murky for niche brands, CBD brand Sunday Scaries looks to OOH as a workaround.
How work-anywhere trend helped Vista attracted senior talent from heavy hitter brands
A remote-first, flexible working operating model has enabled Vista to snag top talent from major brands like Nike, Spotify, Converse and Netflix in the last year.
Quontic Bank’s metaverse outpost demonstrates the importance of brand utility in metaverse activations
Legal concerns notwithstanding, Quontic’s plans for its Decentraland location show that the bank is approaching the metaverse as a functional space for every day use, rather than an escape from reality.
SponsoredHow marketers and retailers are unlocking the true value of retail media
Ben Kneen, senior director of product management, Xandr It’s a challenging time for retailers in the advertising industry. As they cope with supply chain woes and inflation-related pressures, they seek high-margin revenue streams amid evolving privacy regulations and massive shifts in identity solutions — including IDFA, the deprecation of third-party cookies and more. In light […]
‘Cost conscious consumers, restrictive economy’: Advertising’s tough ride in 2022
The big issue for advertisers from an ad spending impact isn't the war in Europe. It’s the supply chain woes emanating from china, the pandemic and the lockdown
In-game advertising experts question Microsoft and Sony’s gaming advertising plans
The importance of free-to-play titles is one reason why some in-game advertising experts are skeptical about the tech giants’ ability to succeed in their chosen business.