Why is third-party data still often wrong?
Data may be everywhere, but it often isn’t worth a damn.
Despite how invasive some people may feel digital data collection might be, targeters still have trouble differentiating basic demographic traits such as age and gender. “A lot of the data that informs programmatic media buying is unreliable and conflicting,” said an ad tech exec who requested anonymity. “So what brands are spending their money for isn’t necessarily the thing they think they are spending their money for.”
In this edition of “Internet Mysteries,” we examine why third-party data still has trouble identifying people’s most basic characteristics.
At the Digiday Programmatic Summit in November, Matt Rosenberg, then CMO of ChoiceStream, highlighted the imperatives that third-party data providers operate under.
“Advertisers need scale, and as a data vendor, if you can’t provide that, no one will buy your segment,” he said.
But in order to reach scale, accuracy often gets sacrificed. As Rosenberg put it: “If you can get 300,000 people in a group with 95 percent confidence that they belong there, or 30 million people in a group with 60 percent confidence, well, it might not be such a hard decision to relax your model a bit, especially when no one is set up to audit you.”
In one study, ChoiceStream found that a particular data vendor had identified 84 percent of users as both male and female. While that case was an extreme outlier, ChoiceStream also examined the two vendors that were least likely to identify people as both male and female. By getting the third-party data internally from the vendors and syncing IDs across datasets, ChoiceStream found about a third of the time the two vendors disagreed on what gender an individual was. Similarly, Mediasmith research found that data from four of 11 vendors wasn’t much better than chance in targeting age and gender.
Why does this still happen?
According to several sources, these inaccuracies persist because of poor incentives. In a thirsty quest for scale, marketers abandon their concerns about certainty. And middlemen are paid based on their number of transactions, and not upon their accuracy. While advertising’s tech capabilities may have gotten much more sophisticated in recent years, priorities haven’t changed as quickly.
“Unless the agency gets pressure from the brand to hold the data company’s feet to the fire, you get a system that is running on its inertia, but that is not really doing the job it is supposed to do,” said an ad tech exec.
What can be done?
Sources emphasized that the quality of data vendors varies widely — and that their data isn’t always crap.
“The key to navigating this landmine of good and bad vendors is to hire the right marketing agency with the right skills, experience and methodology of their own for determining the highest quality sources of inventory and data,” said Mark Paci, COO of Huddled Masses.
Marcus Pratt, Mediasmith vp of insights and tech, noted that in recent years some vendors have expanded their offerings to include data packages at various levels of scale and accuracy, and that these vendors have been more upfront about which packages have the least accuracy. So if advertisers want more accuracy, they can choose the product that best suits them.
Other sources stressed that advertisers need to more persistent in questioning data firms’ methodologies. One source suggested checking third-party data against proprietary surveys or monitoring targeted campaigns with tools from Nielsen and comScore, though these services also prompt their own fees and tradeoffs.
Some brands can also skirt data vendors by relying on their own first-party data. However, many brands don’t have that much useful first-party data to begin with.
Theoretically, a data management platform (DMP) could allow brands to link their own data to third-party data, which could give them a chance to validate the accuracy of third-party sources. But using a DMP creates another middleman with its own set of incentives and costs, and not all marketers are up to speed on how to gather and interpret data in a DMP to make informed buying decisions.
“The thing is,” a programmatic buyer said, “as an advertiser, you have to ask yourself how many asterisks are you willing to accept.”
‘I felt like I was pushed into being a stay-at-home mom’: Confessions of a former ad exec on being fired after becoming a mother
In this edition of our Confessions series, where we exchange anonymity for candor, we hear from a former agency director about getting fired and struggling to find a job amidst navigating motherhood and launching a new project.
To get the attention of millennials and Gen Z, Ace Hardware is turning to influencers
Ace Hardware is adding a paid and organic influencer strategy to its marketing mix to allow the brand to make content that “doesn’t feel like an ad."
‘The world of either is behind us’: Marketers predict the future of events will be a hybrid of online, in-person
Hybrid events, combining in-person programming with an online experience, are likely to become the norm as the vaccine rollout and general return to life continues.
SponsoredVideo: How employer rewards and incentives changed in 2020
The nature of employer rewards programs has transformed, accelerated by the events of 2020 — a year of sweeping change. Employees shifted to digital, their preferences moved to digital wallets and they asked for new and surprising ways to use the rewards their employers delivered. In these new interviews, employer rewards experts talk about the evolving […]
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: With Cannes Lions once again virtual, the ‘networking and dealmaking is likely the biggest casualty’
The promise of another virtual event when many execs are Zoomed out and feel like it’s impossible to unplug from daily work for a virtual event has some questioning what attendance or networking will be like.
Cheat Sheet: Pinterest’s new rules hold creators accountable for posting brand-safe content
Pinterest's "Creator Code" mandatory content policy guidelines will keep its content creators in check, ensuring Story Pins adhere to the tone and brand-safe messaging Pinterest wants to market.