Digiday+ Member Poll: It’s a conflict for consulting firms to conduct media buying
Consulting firms have waded into the advertising world in recent years in an attempt to compete with cumbersome holding companies with their own campaign strategy and creative services. Accenture, PWC, Deloitte, and others have acquired dozens of marketing and digital agencies between them to bolster such capabilities.
But until recently, consulting firms refrained from conducting media buying on behalf of clients, claiming a disinterest in low-margin businesses. That changed recently with Accenture Interactive’s announcement that it will begin pitching for clients’ media budgets, and now people are crying foul.
In an online poll of 24 Digiday+ members held last month on whether it’s a conflict of interests if consultants conduct media buying, the majority agreed that it did constitute a conflict of interest.
The issue the advertising industry has with consulting firms buying media is primarily the fact that those firms currently act as “independent” auditors of brands’ media spend. Some argue whichever company transacts the media can not be an independent auditor, since it has a clear advantage to enshrine their results while downplaying their competitors. Accenture claims it will avoid any conflicts because it won’t audit the companies that it purchases media for.
Part of the outcry among agencies and the digital media industry is likely due to the fact that media buyers feel increasingly challenged by consultancies. An earlier Digiday survey of media buyers found that 76 percent believe consultancies pose a competitive threat to media-buying agencies. Another issue is that now that Accenture has entered the media buying business, it leaves few independent auditors to use.
Advertisers themselves are unlikely to care about potential conflicts on interests consulting firms may have. Even though issues of transparency in media buying were brought to light by a 2016 report by the Association of National Advertisers, it still remained a top issue for advertisers according to a recent Digiday survey. Advertisers, it seems, could be willing to accept the risks of potential conflicts of interests if it resolves a problem that massive spending on third-party measurement tools and private marketplaces couldn’t fix.
‘Still getting started’: Coca-Cola’s candid progress report on its in-house plan
Even the biggest and most lauded advertisers struggle with moving more marketing in-house.
Dmexco cofounder wants to create another marquee marketing conference — this time in Miami next year
The Mobile Marketing Association plus a host of industry luminaries are backing the ambitious undertaking planned for April 2023.
‘Supportive to our business’: Industry arbiter Ebiquity eyes growth amid TV measurement woes
The media management firm sees TV measurement (or the lack thereof) stateside as a way into a market that’s proven tough to crack so far.
SponsoredHow companies are improving career mobility to mitigate the Great Resignation￼
Matt Bartels, principal and media practice lead, Alexander Group The pandemic left an indelible mark on businesses around the world. This abrupt market force challenged leaders to reevaluate their business model, think creatively, work collaboratively and aggressively invest in their future or risk becoming obsolete. Unexpectedly, the global workforce reevaluated their lives while re-envisioning their […]
‘This is one thing that we all should be holding hands and charging towards’: How Pinterest’s Zeny Shifferaw is creating space for underrepresented creators
As the creator economy continues to explode, Pinterest's Zeny Shifferaw works to ensure there's a seat at the table for marginalized communities.
Can contextual provide a better solution than cookie-replacement options, asks the MMA
A new report in conjunction with BCG finds marketers still seem stuck in second gear when it comes to finding alternatives to cookies.