Quartz’s Jay Lauf: Being completely ad-dependent was never good for anybody
Quartz is onto its next big move to diversify reader revenue. The publisher, which originally launched as an ad-supported model, launched a membership program in November.
“Being completely ad-dependent was never good for anybody,” said Jay Lauf, co-CEO of Quartz, on the Digiday Podcast. “It is true, that was the original premise [at Quartz]. A lot of competitive sets were behind paywalls and they were suppressing their traffic potential and the reach they could get. So our wide opening was to get a large advertising base and build a foundation to start. But the idea of reaching business professionals was that along the line, you could create other products that could get closer to utility for this audience and that they may pay for. That’s what we’re at the beginning of exploring now.”
Its efforts are bolstered by its acquisition in June 2018, when the six-year-old business news startup was sold to Japanese financial publisher Uzabase, in a deal valuing Quartz between $75 million to $110 million. In an era where digital media companies are getting sold in fire sales, Quartz remains a brighter spot in the industry. Its strategy: Stay differentiated, and don’t try to be everything to everyone.
“Quartz has an interest to do something different and counterintuitive,” Lauf said. “The first thing we started to suss out was strategy. We had a shared strategy to serve new global business professionals. The second thing we vetted was culture. When you go to the Uzabase website, they uncannily match up with Quartz’s. It’s things like speed, putting users first, having a global view. It really made us sit up and notice in the early parts of the conversation.”
Lauf discusses the subscriptions business, why Quartz remained valuable as a company in the time of fire sales and more. Edited highlights below.
Avoid pivots to stay valuable.
“We were never trying to cash into the trend of the moment. We’ve developed a distinct quality of journalism. We’ve been really dogged about the advertising proposition and our user experience. It’s attracted a loyal fan base. Uzabase is a part of the fan base. It’s a meaningful brand on which you can build. The strategy was to serve a very specific audience. That focus is critical and it has helped us to avoid pivots. We’ve experimented but we’ve never made a full pivot.”
Subscriptions was a conversation long before Uzabase came into the picture.
“We launched our own membership program on Nov. 13. It’s exclusive content that we’re asking members to pay for. That was on the drawing board long before the Uzabase conversations began. We’re moving forward with our original assumptions around what that would like. We developed those at Quartz. What we’re learning from Uzabase is cadence of subscriber content, the kind of things that trigger people to shift from free to paid and we’re being circumspect about whether the Japanese market is idiosyncratic in its own way. The rest of the world might be completely different.”
The value proposition of metered paywalls is unclear.
“We’ve created a wide user funnel with the 20 million people that visit the site every month. Further down the funnel are loyalists who are subscribers of our daily brief, the Quartz Brief app, our newsletters and such. You don’t want to lose that group but you want to lose the opportunity to grow that audience. What you see is going deeper into certain verticals, the users will pay for that. So rather than trying to arbitrarily decide if a news story should go behind a paywall, we’re focusing on our membership content with chapters that make you smarter. It’s less clear to me what the metered proposition is for a user. It seems potentially arbitrary to me. Giving people a more specific proposition is better. If we do it right, we will have membership content that will break out on its own and create more awareness for Quartz.”
Scale is long over.
“If you have to survive, you have to be indispensable for your audience in some way. People need to engage with you every morning. Even Oath at its scale is not able to compete on scale, so give up the scale game. It says a lot about the ad market but also the consumer market. In this political climate, we’re beginning to wake up the fact that for trusted sources, you may have to pay for them and support them.”
How TikTok is taking lessons from the record industry in building a media business
Much of the industry conversation surrounding the app has centered on its ads business but its the creators on it that could spring the bigger returns.
Why TikTok stars are pivoting to gaming
Dressler and Waud used to derive a significant portion of their income selling merchandise to their fans on tours or at meet-ups. However, as these events have been canceled due to coronavirus and stay-at-home orders, they’ve sought to find another source of revenue online.
TheScore CEO John Levy on why sports betting is going mainstream
Consuming sports and betting on them usually happen in two different places. "If you look at the traditional way sports betting has been launched in Europe and even in North America -- in the offshore and black markets -- how people bet is through betting apps," according to John Levy, CEO of theScore, a Canadian sports media company. Those apps aren't where betters get their actual score lines and injury updates; they're where gamblers turn to once they've watched the game or read about it elsewhere. His company is looking to bridge that gap.
SponsoredVideo advertisers are turning to format innovation to push beyond interruptive experiences
In a new video, experts from GumGum, The Martin Agency and Pinterest discuss the future of video advertising — and outline their vision for how video ads can be less disruptive.
‘Less tangible for brands’: Marketers pull back from Pride Month sponsorships
Pride Month has become an economic engine, with brands pouring money into sponsorships for the many celebrations that normally take place nationwide. But with lockdown orders still in effect in many states, Pride Month in 2020 will be far different.
Member Exclusive‘You have full permission to hit the reset button’: Why marketers are using this period to experiment
With coronavirus tearing a hole through the 2020 marketing plan, some marketers see room for risk.