The industry is looking to first-party data to replace cookies, but the open web may lose out
The online advertising industry is in search of a new identity. One potential solution: people’s email addresses or phone numbers.
At the Interactive Advertising Bureau’s Annual Leadership Meeting in Palm Springs, California, on Feb. 10, the IAB Tech Lab proposed developing a new identifier based on people’s email addresses or phone numbers, which provide a more consistent, deterministic way of recognizing someone than the third-party cookie ever did.
The IAB is far from the only entity seeking to build the third-party cookie’s replacement on this first-party data. Executives from ad agencies, publishers and ad tech firms are also looking to buttress the future of online advertising on email addresses and/or phone numbers. They have seen Facebook and Google dominate the online advertising market thanks to their platforms’ logged-in user bases and see email- and phone-based identifiers as a way for the open web to rival the walled gardens. “There has to be a standard identifier, and most likely that is going to be based on an email address,” said one ad tech executive.
However, the industry may be looking in the wrong direction, and hinging the cookie’s replacement on first-party data is unlikely to benefit the open web as a whole. “The people with signed-in users are going to win,” said Megan Pagliuca, chief media and data officer at Hearts & Science. In this case, grounding the identifier on first-party data will create “more of a disadvantage for the mid-tier and long-tail publishers that don’t have [a sizable number of registered users],” Pagliuca said.
If publishers are pressured to press people to provide their email addresses or phone numbers in order to protect their advertising businesses, that will likely lead to more sites putting their content behind so-called “registration walls” so that only logged-in users can access it. While that could help the publishers to accrue user registries, it could also cause them to lose a portion of their audiences. “There are some publishers that will tell you [that] if you put a registration wall in, you will lose users,” said John Gentry, CEO of supply-side platform provider OpenX.
This potential negative impact on small- and mid-sized publishers could lead to an unforeseen consequence: “Do ad networks have the chance of returning?” asked one publishing executive, hypothetically but in earnest.
Ad networks originated as a way for small publishers, including individual bloggers, to pool their sites’ ad inventory together for the ad networks to sell on their behalf. Eventually, supply-side platforms stepped in and replaced the ad networks by dropping third-party cookies on these sites in order to auction off their inventory to programmatically sell targeted ads.
However, in a world without the third-party cookie, these smaller publishers that struggle to collect people’s email addresses or phone networks may once again need to band together under the umbrella of the ad network.
“I could see the long tail get disproportionately affected and then ad networks come back to help with that,” said an executive at an SSP provider.
Ad networks may struggle to attract advertisers because they are generally not transparent about where an advertiser’s ad appeared. But, that would only apply to brand advertisers who care about the context in which their ads appear and not performance advertisers who care about whether an ad led to a sale or other conversion event, like someone visiting the advertiser’s site.“I could see a world where performance buyers return to using ad networks because they don’t care about transparency,” said the unnamed SSP executive.
The potential for the ad network’s return was concerning to one executive at a major publisher because of the possibility for the ad networks to siphon some of the publisher’s revenue. While some ad buyers may direct their dollars to those bigger publishers that have signed-in users, others may see ad networks offering lower prices and sufficient performance and move their money in that direction as a cost-savings measure. “Our industry buys good enough more than it should,” said the executive at the major publisher.
Havas Sports & Entertainment, Haymarket Automotive Studio and the International Paralympic Committee are Digiday Media Awards Europe winners in 2021
The 2021 Digiday Media Awards Europe honors the companies, technologies and campaigns that have modernized European media over the past year.
‘You can’t show empathy over email’: Business leaders turn to internal podcasts to stay connected with workforces
As screen fatigue takes hold, businesses have got creative with internal podcasts as an alternative to Zoom and Teams calls and internal email newsletters.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: Publishers are polling site visitors for first-party data
A growing number of publishers are trying to solve their first-party data problems by literally asking as many questions as possible.
Sponsored75% of people watch mobile videos on mute: What that means for advertisers
Dan Greenberg, president, Sharethrough Recent research into mobile video consumption behavior illustrates a change in human behavior that has implications for the shifting media landscape. Data shows that, unsurprisingly, rather than keep the sound on, 63% of people keep their phone on mute. What may be surprising is that 75% of people say they often […]
Publishers add more online education programs following interest spurred by the pandemic
Publishers like Rolling Stone, WWD and The Wall Street Journal are producing more online education programs this year after the pandemic led to increased interest in digital learning opportunities.
Vox Media’s Marty Moe and Preet Bharara are building a business that extends beyond podcasting
Cafe Studios has debuted its first new show since being acquired by Vox Media, and the companies are looking to expand the podcaster into TV and live events.