Digiday Research: Publishers’ biggest subscription challenges
This research is based on unique data collected from our proprietary audience of publisher, agency, brand and tech insiders. It’s available to Digiday+ members. More from the series →
Subscriptions are in vogue for publishers as they increasingly attempt to generate revenue directly from their audiences instead of through advertising. But building subscription businesses isn’t easy, and publishers say the biggest challenges are the basic ones: Figuring out a product that people will pay for, and then figuring out how to drive conversions.
Sixty-three percent of publishers polled at the Digiday Hot Topic: Subscriptions and Memberships event in August said turning audiences into paying subscribers is a key challenge when creating subscription products, while forty-two percent pointed to developing products people will pay for.
There’s no shortage of free content available online, so many publishers are working to differentiate the content they’re attempting to charge for. Some are packaging together other benefits and perks. The Information (is experimenting with members-only conference calls and commenting capabilities, for example, while Variety offers additional industry research and event discounts to compliment unlimited content access. Others are experimenting with offering access to editors, interactive tools, Facebook Groups, data visualizations and even digital butlers.
But creating a subscription product doesn’t necessarily mean people will buy it. Publishers might be extremely adept at driving traffic and generating pageviews, for example, but convincing users to make purchases requires a different skillset and a different mindset. Many publishers are finding they need to build marketing and ecommerce capabilities and strategies they didn’t have previously, and finding the talent to do so isn’t easy.
Another issue many publishers are coming to terms with is that their actual audiences are far smaller than they’d thought. Publishers who relied on large amounts of traffic from Facebook and struggled to build meaningful brands or direct connections with their audiences may find it difficult to attract paying subscribers in the way more established brands and publishers might be able to.
More in Media
The case for and against publishers buying paid traffic
For many audience development teams, the question is no longer whether to buy traffic, but how far they can push it.
Uber Advertising, the NFL, WPP Media and Mazda are among the finalists of the 2026 Digiday Media Buying and Planning Awards
The Digiday Media Buying and Planning Awards recognize companies, campaigns and technology that have been most successful in the modern media landscape. This year’s nominees leaned on emotionally driven narratives and audience-driven personalizations to deliver connected, full-funnel experiences at scale. Nominees in the Media Campaign of the Year category include Uber Advertising, which built a […]
Why retailers like Target and Aerie are moving beyond straight affiliate deals with creators
Creator programs are changing as retailers like Target and Aerie realize they require a multifaceted approach that doesn’t just rely on affiliate links.