The state of ads.txt
Launched by the Interactive Advertising Bureau Tech Lab in May, ads.txt is a text file that publishers host on their web servers that lists all the companies authorized to sell their inventory. Because ads.txt allows buyers to check the validity of the sellers they purchase from, it should help buyers avoid spoofed domains and arbitraged inventory.
Here’s what you need to know about the state of ads.txt.
- Uptake has increased a lot in the past few months. More than 90,000 sites now use ads.txt, up from 3,500 in September, according to Pixalate. Among the top 1,000 sites that sell programmatic ads, 57 percent now have ads.txt files, compared to 16 percent in September, per Pixalate.
- Domain spoofing remains popular on programmatic exchanges. A recent study of a group of 16 publishers — including The Washington Post, Turner, Business Insider, The New York Times and USA Today — found that advertisers spent $3.5 million a day on fake video inventory that falsely claims to come from their sites.
- Most of the line items on publishers’ ads.txt files are for resellers. Among the top 1,000 Alexa sites, 76 percent of the vendors listed on their ads.txt files are resellers, according to FirstImpression’s ads.txt dashboard.
- About 16 percent of the top 1,000 Alexa sites have formatting errors in their ads.txt files, according to FirstImpression.
- Google, which did more to popularize ads.txt than any other company in the ad industry, is by far the most popular vendor on publisher’s ads.txt files. Google is listed on 97 percent of all ads.txt files, according to Pixalate. AppNexus and Rubicon Project are the only other vendors that top 50 percent.
The sell-side view
Because ad buyers are funneling their dollars through publishers that have ads.txt files, ad rates in Google’s ad exchange are rising. This will make it more difficult for long-tail sites to earn ad revenue, said CafeMedia co-founder Paul Bannister.
“It is like picking up a stone and seeing all the bugs under it,” he said. “You know something was there, but you are like, ‘Whoa, that’s a lot of stuff.’”
The buy-side view
Enough publishers have adopted ads.txt that small-budget campaigns can run exclusively on sites that have ads.txt files, said Matthew McIntyre, activation director at ad agency Essence. Large campaigns, however, still need to pull in publishers that haven’t adopted the tool. About 60 percent of the inventory that Essence buys on the open exchange comes from sites that have verified ads.txt files.
One trade-off for advertisers is that ads.txt is raising premium publishers’ programmatic ad rates. But because ads.txt helps mitigate domain spoofing, the higher ad prices should coincide with ads that perform better, McIntyre said.
What it means for the industry
Ad buyers, publishers, vendors and industry groups continue to adopt ads.txt. Just last week, the Trustworthy Accountability Group announced that publishers will have to implement ads.txt in order to get TAG certification.
The widespread adoption of ads.txt over the past few months puts pressure on vendors that don’t have access to unique inventory. This pressure is reflected by resellers that ask publishers to list them on their ads.txt files, even when the publishers don’t have a relationship with the vendors.
Most publishers and advertisers consider ads.txt a positive step toward cleaning up the murky ad-supply chain. But despite the breathless conference panels that ads.txt inspires, it has its limits as a fraud-fighting tool. Publishers misspell vendor names in their files, leading buyers that filter inventory with ads.txt to inadvertently bypass the publishers’ inventory. It also doesn’t prevent middlemen from repacking display inventory as video and arbitraging the difference between display and video CPMs.
“The fact that the industry has had to create a standard around counterfeit inventory means that as an ecosystem we’ve lost our way,” said Nick Jordan, co-founder of data platform Narrative. “Basically, it is a technology solution to a much more insidious and systemic problem and akin to fixing a compound fracture with stitches.”
Broken windows, ‘cuddling breaks’ and interrupted video calls: Parents share realities of juggling work while homeschooling kids
After almost a year of rolling lockdowns, school closures and lack of access to childcare, parents are tired but laughing at the chaos.
‘More ad dollars move to Snapchat’: Why direct-to-consumer brands eye the platform as they diversify from Facebook
DTC advertisers are looking to make sure they aren’t reliant on a single platform and are exploring to spend more on Snapchat.
‘They don’t really want me to have a voice’: Black women in PR say they feel isolated, held to different standards from their colleagues
Black women who Digiday spoke to believe PR agencies need to reexamine internal culture and hiring practices to become more inclusive.
SponsoredShoppable content is reshaping brand and publisher relationships
In recent years, brands and publishers have adopted affiliate marketing as an increasingly established method to audiences. However, what may seem to be a mutually beneficial arrangement between brands and affiliates on closer scrutiny reveals itself as a solution that comes with challenges. Meanwhile, the emergence of content commerce is opening different approaches to matching […]
How a DTC wine brand is finding first-party data in SMS
One DTC wine brand is looking to invest more heavily in SMS and text messaging communication to reach users and grow its first-party data.
‘Endless digital shelf’: Why some DTC brands are doubling efforts on Amazon
DTC brands are shifting ad and marketing dollars that were set aside for in-field marketing efforts to e-commerce.