Fearing brand safety turmoil, marketers are whitelisting influencers
Whitelists have become of interest for brands looking to make sure their ads only appear in pre-approved places. Instead of blacklists, which can end up being a game of whack-a-mole, whitelists, while less scaleable and more expensive, can actually provide a better guarantee of not having an ad next to porn content — or worse.
Now, a growing number of companies are testing influencer whitelists: Creating pre-approved lists of influencers that brands can work with, and in some cases, get unfettered, open access to their handles.
Against the backdrop of brand safety, the issue becomes more prevalent. One marketing executive, who spoke to Digiday under condition of anonymity, said that he’s been “burned” by influencers who have taken his product, then posted content in “unsavory” ways that he said were “disgusting.”
There have been flubs in the space. Perhaps the biggest one was when YouTube star PewDiePie posted videos with anti-Semitic jokes, costing him the business of brands including Disney and YouTube. Shortly after, in February, influencer and CoverGirl ambassador James Charles tweeted a joke about going to Africa and catching Ebola alongside a CoverGirl-sponsored tweet. And for influencers, it’s not just about so-called “brand safety” issues. Companies are also looking for influencers who haven’t worked with similar brands, or sometimes, haven’t worked with brands at all.
And so, just like publishers are held accountable, so should influencers. “When you think about the repercussions and the issues that have come up, brands really have to think: They’re putting their identity and credibility in the hands of the influencer,” said 360i head of influencer marketing Corey Martin.
It’s a common problem. Brands who know they want to get into influencer marketing often do a “spray and pray” approach, assigning hundreds of social stars an assignment, which means they then have full authority to post things on their own platforms using their brands with no real safety mechanisms.
Whitelists can help. 360i uses “a list of trusted, authentic followers.” The agency hangs its hat on a concept it calls “accountable influence,” and makes a list based on the following criteria: credibility, past behavior and tonality.
Whitelists vary in nature.
For example, when Microsoft, which works with influencer marketing agency Little Bird, wanted to advertise its “Skype in the classroom” project, it used its whitelist system to find teachers who were also socially active and those that other educators follow. Little Bird uses a whitelist based on “peer validation,” a list of communities that have the respect of peers.
At Hashoff, an influencer marketing platform, the company has built a whitelist of “thousands” of influencer. How it works: it connects influencer accounts on the backend through a PMP partnership, which aggregates a list. Then, they whitelist then based on attributes like hashtags, what brands the influencer has already worked with and other keywords. “Brand safety is something we’re keenly aware of,” said CEO Joel Wright. “We need to analyze four years worth of content from influencers.” Hashoff’s list is based on Google’s list of 1,000 terms in English that are deemed inappropriate. They include “God” and “politics.”
One major aspect, other than obvious things like politically slanted posts or brand-unsafe things like pornographic content, is to use influencers who have not previously worked with other brands in the same field or category. Some brands want influencers who’ve never worked with anyone else. Whitelists can be tweaked to only include those.
Whitelists have become necessary because of how the market has evolved. Brands originally dipped a toe in influencer marketing by just getting creators to make posts. Now, they’re putting money behind those posts, often also using what influencers make in their paid advertising.
“What has occurred in the next stage is if you’re running campaigns with talent is to enhance the reach of that piece of content as a brand by buying ads through the brand’s channel,” said WhoSay CEO Steve Ellis. (That differs on platforms. On Facebook, it’s known as a handshake, where users see an influencer content “with” a brand.) When you put money behind something, it becomes more imperative that it appear in the right place. And it’s likelier that your brand is more obvious. So using an influencer who ends up spouting racist things, getting too political or heavens forbid, has lost authenticity because he commoditized his offerings by working with every company under the sun can get really problematic, really fast.
Some firms are bargaining for whitelists to go both ways. Ellis of WhoSay recounts working with a major brand who was asking access to an influencer’s whitelisted handle to promote a show. Ellis said influencers who are big enough celebrities then will also ask for unfettered, whitelisted access to the brand’s own channel and post stuff on there. “It’s a two way street,” he said. “The influencer’s network is an asset too.”
Member Exclusive‘Truly integrated’: As an unusual school year commences, agencies are aiming to help working parents more than ever before
Agencies, which have long had reputations as difficult work environments for working parents, are adapting to be more flexible for parents this year.
‘How much do we want to get screwed?’: Confessions of an agency exec on lack of payment due to coronavirus
In the latest edition of our Confessions series, we hear from one agency exec who says that the “times are tough” excuse for late client payments isn’t cutting it anymore.
‘Doubling down’: Inside the 49ers social and digital rush to replace lost in-stadium marketing dollars
Without the ability to deliver ads to the 70,000 fans who attend games in-person, the 49ers have had to pivot to focus on digital and social channels.
SponsoredB2B events were broken before the pandemic, their online reinvention is creating positive change
Kim Darling, executive producer, Inbound Farewell lanyards, business cards and branded pens — it’ll be some time before people get their hands on these souvenirs of in-person events again. As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to transform the way people work, buy, sell, socialize and entertain themselves, the global events industry is facing its biggest-ever challenge. […]
Member Exclusive‘Can’t really be ignored’: Marketers and media buyers are finally taking the on-going TikTok saga seriously
Marketers and media buyers have said that as long as people are still on TikTok they’ll want to be there, especially as they try to diversify from Facebook and Google.
‘Clever about how we rest’: As uncertainties drag into fall, agencies are facing a burnt out and fearful workforce
Agency employees and executives say that a feeling of fatigue due to the on-going uncertainty and the need to be always on has set in.