It’s hard to remember now, but there was a time when Apple was pretty much an afterthought, a cautionary tale of a young company that tried to keep too much control. It lagged far behind the open Windows system in favor of a command-and-control approach of a tightly integrated product, with ultimate control resting firmly in Cupertino.
We know how that story ended. With Apple ascendant, it only makes sense that other industries will look to emulate its success in their own way. Publishers can also learn from Apple’s total control over product, argue Buzzfeed CEO Jonah Peretti and president Jon Steinberg in a new blog post. The executives compare the Buzzfeed approach — integrate ad tech and editorial tech in homegrown systems and even exert control over the creative itself — with the typical publisher approach that outsources bits of its business to others and relies on advertisers and their agencies to supply ads that may or may not fit with the audience.
Our end to end approach is what makes it possible but skepticism was understandable given the state of the industry. Usually one agency creates the ad, another buys the media, a few publishers traffic it, another company measures the results, nobody sees the big picture, and good ideas get lost. Working with BuzzFeed requires that everyone collaborate on an integrated campaign with creative, media, and measurement all tightly integrated. The results speak for themselves: CTRs that are 10x to 20x industry averages, earned media averaging 38 percent (median) to 58 percent (mean) most recently for campaigns concluding in Q1 (with a minimum budget level), and enormous brand lifts. Tight vertical integration isn’t just the future of tech, it is the future of publishing and advertising as well.
It’s a tempting conclusion, and it fits with the recent trend toward new-style publishers like BuzzFeed, The Huffington Post, Gawker and Vox Media seeing themselves as tech companies. It’s easy for a business to claim to be a tech company — all firms use technology, after all — but most publishers still don’t see technology as one of their core competencies. Instead it is viewed as a support function, with the main role being played by editors producing the content. That role will always remain important, no doubt, but the Buzzfeed approach is evidence that publishers will need to be more assertive if they’re going to escape the commoditization trap where an impression is an impression, often irrespective of context.
You have read the maximum number of free articles.
This content is available exclusively to Digiday+ members.
Sign up to get the day’s top stories at 6am eastern.