Why the publisher waterfall isn’t dead yet
Legacy tech can be inescapable, even for programmatic advertisers.
Although newer (and allegedly more efficient) programmatic methods have emerged since the waterfall’s glory days, it’s worth noting that the waterfall is far from dead. Some publishers have held out from header bidding — its much buzzed-about alternative — and still rely heavily on waterfalling. And others implement waterfalls through a mixed approach to sell off remnant impressions.
“The waterfall is still a good tool to maximize remaining inventory,” said Ido Pollak, CTO of ad tech firm Matomy. “There is no single magic solution that does everything.”
It’s easy to assume that the waterfall — which let publishers move their inventory from one market to the next in an effort to optimize revenue — has died. After all, header bidding was said to have replaced it by allowing publishers to offer inventory to multiple exchanges before making calls to their ad servers. And now header bidding itself risks being usurped by server-to-server connections, which move bidding actions from publishers’ pages to a server, which allows pages to load faster. But waterfalling still exists, and here’s why.
For some publishers, the investment of setting up and running complex header bidders or server-to-server connections just isn’t worth it. That’s why publishers such as The Financial Times and BBC have held out from header bidding altogether. Header bidding and server-to-server holdouts may become less common over time, but, nonetheless, there still are publishers holding out, and these publishers often push much of their inventory through a waterfall.
Latency concerns have been another major reason why some publishers haven’t adopted header bidding.
“There is finite space on the header,” said Jason Tollestrup, director of programmatic at The Washington Post. “If you run 100 header bidders, your page will load slowly. Running header bidding without being thoughtful about it can actually be hurtful.”
Tanuj Joshi, vp of programmatic partnerships at MediaMath, said that publishers sometimes use a variety of methods to fill their inventory. So even if a publisher sells most of their programmatic inventory through header bidding, the waterfall can still be used as a backup method to sell remaining impressions.
Thought Catalog is one publisher that complements their heading bidding with a waterfall.
“Our reason behind this mixed strategy is we only have a few header partners integrated at the moment, and we still need a way to monetize 100 percent of our inventory,” said Cristina Calderin, Thought Catalog director of programmatic. “The waterfall comes in handy for that, to help us backfill. … Header bidding is certainly a smarter way to buy and sell inventory, but it’s not always feasible to include enough [header-bidding partners] that they buy up all of a publisher’s impressions.”
Sources noted although advanced techniques like server-to-server are becoming more popular, header bidding is still early on the radar for some publishers. Sources also noted that many technologies (e.g., ad networks, banner ads) stick around long after a more efficient replacement becomes available, and the waterfall is not exempt from this trend.
“I’m skeptical [that the end of the waterfall is near],” said Julie Clark, vp of programmatic sales and strategy at Hearst. “Because people will still find that [antiquated] market.”
‘The pressure cooker is primed to explode’: How instant messaging tools are contributing to burnout
Despite their many benefits, instant-messaging tools like Slack have contributed to burnout over the last year — leading some businesses to drop them entirely.
Member ExclusiveGaming Advertising Forum Recap: Rapidly growing sector’s massive platforms and user diversity underestimated
Digiday’s Gaming Advertising Forum invited industry insiders and thought leaders from brands, gaming platforms and ad tech companies to take the industry’s pulse.
Heated founder Emily Atkin shows what it takes to make the transition from staff writer to Substacker
Substack is now a full-time job for Emily Atkin and her subscriber base has grown large enough for her to hire her first employee.
SponsoredWhat sustainable app monetization looks like in 2021
Apple’s iOS 14 changes are driving significant shifts in the app ecosystem. For gaming businesses, these new changes will make it challenging to show targeted ads. That said, the mobile game economy continues to boom, and analysts predict long-term growth; global in-app ad revenue in 2021 will rise by 6.2% for non-gaming apps, and 19.1% […]
Why temporary email apps could disrupt identity tech and publishers’ first-party data strategies
Apps that generate fake one-time emails can create just one more disruption to publisher first-party data and identity goals.
Member ExclusiveMedia Buying Briefing: As gaming explodes as an ad medium, media agencies aim to level up
Media buyers are ramping up their efforts to guide clients through the exploding but complex world of marketing in gaming.