How Trinity Mirror is using server-side ad trading to tap brand budgets
Six months after British newspaper group Trinity Mirror integrated a server-to-server solution — the sequel to header bidding — the publisher is getting advertisers to increase their programmatic ad spending. In one test, it reduced an advertiser’s cost per acquisitions by 75 percent and got that advertiser to increase its programmatic spending by 175-fold, according to Trinity Mirror.
The parent of titles including the Daily Mirror and the Daily Record make 60 percent of its display ad inventory available programmatically. For its test, it shifted one-fifth of that to server-side ad auctions and all but dropped header bidding entirely, keeping just Amazon’s header bidding tool. Trinity Mirror improved its ad yields by 17 percent with header bidding.
But it sees server-side’s benefits going beyond higher CPMs, to regaining control over the auction process, reducing the number of ad tech middlemen and getting brand advertisers to spend more on programmatic, which historically has been the domain of direct response.
“Publishers have drawn the short straw for the last 36 months, with the advent of programmatic as well as the duopoly of Google and Facebook,” said Amir Malik, Trinity Mirror’s programmatic chief. “But if we can drive a more intelligent and research-led sale of our media, then using server-to-server and influencing market dynamics will mean we can claw back more autonomy and control of our inventory.”
Server-to-server integration is fast becoming the obsession du jour in the same way header bidding was over the last year. Amazon has rolled out its own cloud-based solution with U.S. publishers, while AppNexus and IndexExchange have paired up to offer a solution.
Trinity Mirror has gone a different route, integrating with ad tech platform Switch, which Malik stressed would act as an independent auditing layer and won’t compete with the publisher on bids.
Using Switch, Trinity Mirror’s team can see all third-party exchanges with a single dashboard. That offers a variety of benefits. For starters, it frees up resources by consolidating five hours of reporting into one. The publisher also gets a better view of advertisers’ buying patterns. That means it can tweak the sell-side algorithms to ensure that as soon as a rival buyer to any Trinity Mirror advertiser pops up in a bid window for an impression, the publisher can manipulate the algorithm to ensure their partner’s bid always wins.
“We believe this could be very disruptive for real-time bidding,” said Malik.
The publisher tried out this method in the past three months with two advertisers, from the telco and travel sectors, across its 80 websites spanning 30 million monthly unique users (comScore).
Before the trial, one of the advertiser’s buyers spent £13 ($16) a day on Trinity Mirror inventory. The publisher then applied the “conditional algorithm” so that every time a core rival to that buyer (such as a DSP or agency trading desk) tried to bid on an impression on behalf of the same advertiser, Trinity Mirror’s own buyer partner won the impression. Based on those results, the buyer increased its daily spend for that advertiser to £2,000 ($2,500) a day and its cost per acquisition dropped 75 percent. Malik plans to expand the server-to-server effort, pitching it to advertisers as a way to reduce their cost of acquisition in exchange for higher spending and guaranteed volume
“The commercials around this are still evolving, but the immediate upside is that the volume of [advertiser] spend grows astronomically,” said Malik.
Server-to-server is touted as being able to provide the same auction possibilities as header bidding, minus the risk of page latencies. But the method has its drawbacks. The main one is user matching being poor on the server-side.
“As soon as you introduce header bidding or server-to-server, you end up with multiple bid requests for every impression, which didn’t exist with the waterfall,” said Ed Lyon, programmatic director for Group M agency Essence. “And every bid request requires work on the DSP side, which pushes up costs to the advertiser, or whoever sits between the demand-side platform and advertiser — the agency.”
But Malik stressed that won’t be an issue, saying that centralizing the view of exchanges will decrease the chances of miscommunication. “Reducing the number of hops between supply-side platforms limits the friction between our buyers and our audience, so the user matching is actually improved,” he said. “Ultimately I have decluttered the sale of my audience, and that is very threatening to the SSPs.”
On paper, the concept is appealing to performance agencies, particularly when it comes to the potential to reduce CPAs. If the test client wasn’t spending much to begin with, you’d expect to see an increase in their spending if their approach got smarter, said James Diba, display and audience planning director at Dentsu Aegis’ performance agency iProspect.
“But to increase it by that much and more than halve the CPA is very interesting, and is something we would want to get on board with,” he said.
‘Qualify the context’: Publishers see success with podcasts created to deepen coronavirus crisis coverage
Publishers expanded COVID-19 coverage with products like podcasts as audiences flocked to pandemic-related content.
‘We need to see ourselves as a media business’: AC Milan’s endgame for content
Italian football club AC Milan has joined the likes of Chelsea, Real Madrid, Barcelona F.C and Bayern Munich in owning its production arm.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: ‘I literally didn’t sleep last night’: Publishers share their concerns about the future of data
Publishing execs today face big questions about how to value their audiences and who holds the keys to that value.
SponsoredShoppable content is reshaping brand and publisher relationships
In recent years, brands and publishers have adopted affiliate marketing as an increasingly established method to audiences. However, what may seem to be a mutually beneficial arrangement between brands and affiliates on closer scrutiny reveals itself as a solution that comes with challenges. Meanwhile, the emergence of content commerce is opening different approaches to matching […]
California’s privacy law has had ‘no impact’ on ad revenues or inventory, but indirect effects could hurt
Publishers, ad tech firms and ad agencies say they felt a bigger hit from opt-ins in Europe than from opt-outs in California.
‘Isolated and voiceless’: Burnt out young workers are turning to tech for mental health support
Gen Z workers think robots are more helpful than humans for mental health support — a factor that hints at deeper work-culture issues.