Media

The Supremes Debate Pharma Data Case

April 27, 2011 | By Carla Rover

Assistant Attorney General Bridget Asay argued on Tuesday that data vendors should have to request permission from doctors to access anonymous data that they have provided to pharmacists. Justice Scalia and Chief Justice Roberts, in an often hilarious back and forth, argued that Vermont simply wanted to block marketers from using data to fine-tune campaigns directed at doctors, so that generic drugs, which are cheaper for the State of Vermont to pay for, would have a fighting chance over big brand names.

The structure of the Justices’ arguments suggest that the Court is moving towards overturning restrictions on anonymous data usage by marketing companies in Vermont. This decision would have wide-ranging effects for the advertising industry as a whole as digital marketers will now have case law from the nation’s highest court which would assert that anonymous data cannot be regulated by states and that a marketing campaign’s methods of connecting with consumers may be classified as free speech in most events. This would also be a blow to consumer data privacy advocates desiring strict limits on how, when and where anonymous data may be transferred and used.

“It’s problematic for the State to make a determination as to what uses information can be put,” stated Chief Justice Roberts. The Supreme Court will rule in June on the matter. Read the full transcript of the conversation here.

https://digiday.com/?p=5905

Digiday Top Stories

Holiday Marketing
Massive political advertising clashes with holiday media buying, creating a ‘tsunami’ effect for Q4
This year, the fourth-quarter ad marketplace feels quite different, and for a number of reasons, some for the better and some not.
Agency Culture
4A’s Marla Kaplowitz on 3 ways agencies can navigate the uncertain economy
The industry trade group is helping many agency members prepare their business for broader economic changes, from how to retain talent to honing their financial acumen.
Content & Commerce
How sportsbooks and publishers are rethinking the terms of content-based sponsorships
The economic slowdown is causing sportsbooks and publishers alike to reconsider their approaches to content-based customer acquisition campaigns.
Sponsored
How marketers are tailoring data-driven creative to engage audiences on CTV
Gabriela Maestre, vice president of creative solutions, Tremor International As the end of the year approaches and marketing teams look to finalize their 2023 budgets, many are wondering how to ensure their ads are set up for success in the months ahead, appealing to unique audiences whose media consumption habits continue to evolve. Advances in […]
Going Global
A year after coming under Axel Springer’s control, Politico’s Europe and North American businesses are closer than ever
Politico is still realizing what a global brand might look like, but Politico EU's CRO Nicolas Sennegon is already pursuing an advertising business that extends across the pond.
Modern Newsroom
How publishers can prevent cyberattacks after Fast Company’s hack
Tech executives shared what publishers can do to prevent getting hacked and avoid cybersecurity breaches.