The PPP divide: While venture-backed publishers get PPP loans, many bootstrapped publishers haven’t
During the last few years in media, venture-backed publishers got to operate one way, while independent publishers had no choice but to operate another. The media world’s experience with the Small Business Administration’s Paycheck Protection Program thus far has felt dismally similar to that dynamic.
Over the past week, smaller publishers have fumed at headlines that several venture-backed media companies. Axios (total capital raised: $57 million, including a $27 million round in December 2019) got a $4.8 million loan. Bustle Digital Group (total funding raised: $80.5 million) received $7.5 million. Meanwhile, many smaller publishers have found themselves shut out. (Axios backtracked and returned its PPP loan on Tuesday, saying it found other funding sources and “the program had become divisive.”)
In private conversations, publishers at small media companies are livid that money intended for small businesses seems to be going to companies that either have access to other sources of funding, or are planning to use the revenue in ways that seem contrary to the PPP’s purpose.
“Morally, I can’t justify it,” said the CEO of one mid-sized digital publisher with fewer than 500 staffers but decided not to apply. “Who are we to ask for PPP? It doesn’t make any sense.”
Bustle Digital Group, which laid off 24 people at the beginning of April, said in a statement this week that it would use the $7.5 million it got from the PPP to expand the hours it was giving to freelancers, while also reducing pay cuts it had instituted recently. BDG would not make an executive available for this story.
Axios CEO Jim VandeHei wrote on Tuesday that forgoing the PPP loan, which was revealed just a week earlier in an Axios piece, was done because of the issue becoming polarized and an unnamed “alternative source” of capital materialized. Axios would not comment on the record or detail the source of capital.
While many media companies were ineligible for the funds – including an estimated two thirds of U.S. newspapers – a number of small companies were able to get their applications approved.
But many of the smaller publishers that have gotten funds so far have done so almost in spite of their banks, rather than because of them. Two smaller publishers that received PPP funding said they got their applications started by obsessively reloading their banks’ websites on the day their application portals were supposed to launch, rather than wait for the banks to announce they were working. The cofounder of one of those publishers said their application had been processed two hours before their bank sent out an announcement that the bank was now accepting applications.
On some level, things have played out this way because of how funds were distributed during the first round of the PPP. Only large banks were able to distribute funds because they already had access to E-Tran, the portal that the SBA uses to process applications.
And aside from rules about the size of the businesses they were to lend to, “the banks had no other guidelines and no other rules,” said Greg Ott, the CEO of Nav, a gateway to loans for small businesses. “So, in some respects, they did what you’d expect them to do: They served their largest and their VIP customers first.”
‘Qualify the context’: Publishers see success with podcasts created to deepen coronavirus crisis coverage
Publishers expanded COVID-19 coverage with products like podcasts as audiences flocked to pandemic-related content.
California’s privacy law has had ‘no impact’ on ad revenues or inventory, but indirect effects could hurt
Publishers, ad tech firms and ad agencies say they felt a bigger hit from opt-ins in Europe than from opt-outs in California.
‘We need to see ourselves as a media business’: AC Milan’s endgame for content
Italian football club AC Milan has joined the likes of Chelsea, Real Madrid, Barcelona F.C and Bayern Munich in owning its production arm.
SponsoredShoppable content is reshaping brand and publisher relationships
In recent years, brands and publishers have adopted affiliate marketing as an increasingly established method to audiences. However, what may seem to be a mutually beneficial arrangement between brands and affiliates on closer scrutiny reveals itself as a solution that comes with challenges. Meanwhile, the emergence of content commerce is opening different approaches to matching […]
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: ‘I literally didn’t sleep last night’: Publishers share their concerns about the future of data
Publishing execs today face big questions about how to value their audiences and who holds the keys to that value.
‘Isolated and voiceless’: Burnt out young workers are turning to tech for mental health support
Gen Z workers think robots are more helpful than humans for mental health support — a factor that hints at deeper work-culture issues.