Many publishers are faced with a math problem. All the new “incremental” revenue lines — commerce, licensing, micropayments, events — don’t add up to more than their declining ad businesses as Google and Facebook suck up ad budgets.
“No single stream of alternative revenue will make up for the declines that we’re seeing in advertising,” said Jim Norton, the former chief business officer at Condé Nast. “There’s no silver bullet. You can’t say, ‘If we’re down 10 percent on advertising, we can make it up through subscriptions.’”
That reality likely means more consolidation for legacy publishers. But in an era where publishers need to keep looking for ways to build and monetize direct relationships with their audiences, these new streams will remain vital.
“We’re essentially a storytelling company that uses data and distribution to acquire an audience,” said Pete Spande, the chief revenue officer of Insider Inc. “We’re looking for new businesses that can monetize our core strengths.”
Publishers have talked about diversifying their revenue for years. And some of them, particularly those that have focused on it for a while, have managed to achieve real successes. Meredith-licensed products, for example, accounted for $22 billion in retail sales in 2016, second only to Disney.
The New York Times, after years of effort, turned consumer revenue into its largest revenue source in 2017. Though that was mostly due to sales of digital news subscriptions, the Times has had so much success with Crossword and Cooking subscriptions that it breaks them out in quarterly earnings reports; Cooking and Crossword combined to generate over $14 million in revenue this past year, a 53 percent increase year over year.
The average publisher now lists six different revenue streams, including branded content, subscriptions, events, membership and affiliate commerce as at least “important” to their business, according to a survey the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism conducted.
Publishers have broadened their focus out of necessity. Even though the digital advertising market is growing healthily — U.S. revenues rose 22.6 percent in the first half of 2017 to $40.1 billion, according to the Interactive Advertising Bureau — an overwhelming majority of that growth is going to Google and Facebook. The duopoly’s share of global advertising has more than doubled over the past four years, growing from just over 10 percent ($45.6 billion) in 2013 to more than 22 percent ($113.6 billion) in 2017, according to Bloomberg analysis.
Those unfavorable market dynamics have made publishers a lot more open-minded. “There was a time when the publishers said, ‘Unless it’s 20 percent of my revenue, I don’t have time to talk to you,’” said Oliver Roup, the CEO of affiliate commerce tool VigLink, who noted he’s seen an uptick in interest among publishers in the last two years. “That attitude has largely gone away.”
It’s not that publishers will glom onto anything to make a quick buck. “We’re not interested in businesses that don’t have a trajectory to become eight- or nine-figure [revenue sources] very soon,” Spande said.
But finding the discipline, resources and patience to focus on something unfamiliar is difficult. “It’s really hard, if you’re a TV broadcasting company, for example, to focus on this really promising million-dollar business [that] requires more care and feeding than the billion-dollar businesses,” Spande said. “You have to get to the place where you’re able to spin many plates at the same time.”
Often, publishers still end up with advertising as the main thrust of their business, no matter the additional lines. Roup, for example, noted that he is fielding more and more requests from publisher clients asking to combine data about their affiliate commerce conversions into VigLink’s digital marketing platform to create audience segments for advertising.
These new businesses have marketing costs, too. Hearst Magazines Digital Media President Troy Young said he wants branded content, commerce and licensing to represent two-thirds of his business. He said it is sometimes difficult at the beginning to remind colleagues that every ad slot used to promote one of those new sorts of businesses comes at the expense of money it could earn from selling that inventory to someone else — often at a higher margin.
“A lot of people see those assets as being freely available,” Young said. “It creates hard conversations internally.”
Transforming from an industry mainly focused on selling ads to a business that sells lots of different things will take time. But it’s a shift publishers need to make.
“It’s a fool’s errand to think you’ll be able to turn the tide on advertising trends,” Norton said. “Everybody has to be committed to alternative streams of revenue, even at the expense of short-term revenue loss. That’s the beam every publisher and media owner needs to balance on.”
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: Publishers and media unions are still haggling over office-return plans heading into the summer
In this week's Media Briefing, senior media reporter Sara Guaglione reports on how unions at some major media companies are pushing back against publishers' return to office mandates, with The New York Times Guild seemingly netting a victory on Wednesday.
‘He thought I was accusing him of being racist’: Confessions of a comms pro on working with out of touch leadership
The [CEO] and one of the other co-founders felt the need to point out that they mentor black people and donate to black-focused charities. 'It wasn't about them, but they were making it about them.'
As economic uncertainty grows, senior media buyers expect decent upfront pricing options across linear and digital
TV sellers face a steeper uphill climb to sell billions of ad time in advance, as market indicators look increasingly gloomy. But that's not stopping one seller from seeking aggressive pricing and volume gains.
SponsoredHow marketers and retailers are unlocking the true value of retail media
Ben Kneen, senior director of product management, Xandr It’s a challenging time for retailers in the advertising industry. As they cope with supply chain woes and inflation-related pressures, they seek high-margin revenue streams amid evolving privacy regulations and massive shifts in identity solutions — including IDFA, the deprecation of third-party cookies and more. In light […]
How Microsoft plans to storm adland: ‘Attribution, CTV, in-game ads and potential M&A’
Microsoft Advertising VP Rob Wilk explains how it plans to burnish its $10bn ad business
Inside Hearst UK’s multi-pronged approach to third-party cookie replacements
Hearst UK's Ryan Buckley and Faye Turner are testing everything from 50,000-person panels to clean rooms.