The war for the bottom of article pages, where content recommendation networks vie for real estate, is heating up — and has a casualty.
On Monday, nRelate said that it’s shutting down five years after its founding. The company, which was acquired by IAC in 2012, says it’s shifting its focus away from external publishers to become an internal tool for IAC’s own properties, according to founders Neil Mody and Oliver Wellington. It will stop serving recommendations to publishers on Dec. 31.
“Simply put, nRelate, the entity that provides recommendations to sites across the web, will no longer be a stand-alone business,” the founders wrote in a blog post on Monday.
Like other content recommendation companies, nRelate offers readers “suggested reading” or “recommended for you” links at the bottom of pages. Some of those links were from advertisers, which generated revenue for nRelate and its partner publishers when readers clicked them. In one deal, NRelate offered a publisher desktop CPMs between $2.50 and $3.00, taking a 30 percent cut from ad revenue.
The news of nRelate’s closing apparently came as a surprise to nRelate business development staff, which called its partner publishers on Monday to inform them of the news, according an exec at one nRelate publisher, who asked to remain anonymous.
NRelate’s failure isn’t too surprising considering the intense competition surrounding the content recommendation space. The likes Outbrain and Taboola are constantly to outbid each other in an effort to sign up more publishers, which, while great for publishers, typically means writing massive upfront checks to the publishers they’re trying to woo. NRelate, which was pitching itself on the quality of its recommendations, likely couldn’t keep up. Yahoo has also poured resources into its own network, making the going even tougher for smaller outfits to compete.
“These things are really commodities for publishers because it’s really easy to switch them in and out,” said the publisher, adding that its typical for publishers to jump from Outbrain to Taboola after their exclusivity deals expire.
NRelate’s demise contrast strongly with that of fellow content recommendation company Outbrain, which is looking to go public with a $1 billion valuation. The company has raised $100 million since its founding in 2006. It’s primary competitor, Taboola, is also heavily venture capital-backed, having raised $40 million so far. The pair also compete with recommendation widgets from big companies AOL and Yahoo, the latter of which entered the space in September.
What’s still not clear is whether the content recommendation space can support many companies or whether only a handful of big players will make it difficult to smaller ones to stay afloat.
More in Media
Will news publishers see another ‘Trump bump’ in Trump’s second term?
Now that Trump has won the presidency again, what does a second Trump administration mean for news publishers? Traffic and video views paint a mixed picture.
Media Briefing: European publishers speak out on advertisers’ punishing brand safety practices
This week’s Media Briefing recaps what publishers had to say behind closed doors during last week’s Digiday Publishing Summit Europe about the brand safety/suitability practices that are penalizing their ad businesses.
At the Digiday Publishing Summit Europe, publishers move away from trend chasing
Despite the publishing industry’s grim outlook, many outliers are simultaneously fighting to change and reluctantly accepting the status quo.