Surprise, small publishers screwed the most by net-neutrality rules
Here’s one more thing for small publishers to worry about: New net-neutrality rules are going to jack up the costs of doing business.
Rolling back net neutrality would relegate independent publishers to the slow lane of the internet because they’d be unable to afford access to high speeds. Large publishers with more cash can overcome this obstacle, but they’ll be hit with onerous fees and face possible competitive disadvantages from subsidiaries of internet-service providers receiving preferential treatment.
“I suspect that ISPs would create different tiers of data transmission speeds and prioritization,” said Fred Lane, an attorney who specializes in emerging technologies. ”Large corporations would be in a position to negotiate preferential treatment in ways not available to smaller content producers.”
Purch CTO John Potter said that large publishers, which are more likely to afford fees associated with faster page loads, would also be disadvantaged by changes in net neutrality since many publishers aren’t that profitable to begin with. An additional tax on internet service would place more pressure on already-struggling business models.
“Publishers prefer the certainty of net neutrality to the uncertainty of rolling it back,” he said.
Unfortunately for concerned publishers, this battle isn’t going away. On Tuesday, tech lobbyists urged the Federal Communications Commission to preserve current rules that prevent ISPs from opening up paid fast lanes. And last week, FCC chairman Ajit Pai reportedly briefed telecom trade groups on his plan to rollback net neutrality.
If Pai gets his wish and guts the rules in place, it could create conflicts of interest because the conglomerates that control the major ISPs also own publishers. Verizon owns AOL and Yahoo, Comcast owns NBC and AT&T has a stake in Otter Media and is trying to merge with Time Warner. So when an ISP like Verizon has its own video-streaming service like Go90, it would have incentive to make Go90 load faster than competitors.
“This system would allow ISPs to raise the cost of the rivals of their affiliates,” said Santa Clara University legal scholar Catherine Sandoval. Lane added, “Preferential treatment for in-house content providers seems very likely.”
Allen Mendelsohn, a lawyer who specializes in internet law, said that publishers could try to recuperate some of the ISP fees by using their newfound speed to drive more ad revenue by raising ad rates or serving more video ads. But those practices are only sustainable if a publisher has great demand for its inventory and the additional ads don’t alienate users.
Net neutrality hasn’t been killed off yet, and even if Pai makes good on his word, it’ll be a while before it’s officially approved by the FCC and ISPs adapt to the new law. But the Trump administration’s bullishness on deregulation doesn’t paint a hopeful picture for the future of equal internet access.
“It is really important that folks recognize how what happens in Washington affects them,” said Dave Morgan, a former attorney and CEO of Simulmedia. “It isn’t the day after a law changes that you see changes in your business. But it is clearly a shift in the balance of power, and it could have a significant degradation on publishers’ business over the course of time.”
‘Giving people more control’: Rise in flexible working is enabling older workers to defer retirement
Enforced working from home has opened many people’s eyes to the potential for flexible working, and for many older people it has offered them a way to defer retirement.
Member ExclusiveMedia Buying Briefing: ‘The golden age of audio’: New forms hit a higher note, but radio buyers still struggle to hear it
As digital audio continues to grow, forecast by eMarketer to hit $5.59 billion in 2021, media buyers and planners are still trying to find ways to make effective use of it.
Publishers boost climate change coverage as the issue takes the world stage
With the countdown to the COP26 summit underway, publishers are boosting their coverage of climate change in videos, articles, events and audio.
SponsoredHow legacy publishers are transforming into profitable streaming channels
Navdeep Saini, co-founder and CEO, DistroScale, parent company of DistroTV Connected TV (CTV) has become one of the fastest developing channels in advertisers’ marketing mix today. The pandemic led to an increase in CTV consumption, with 75% of consumers watching more streaming content than before quarantines set in. With streaming viewership continuing to gain momentum, […]
‘We see a world where publisher data replaces third-party data’: News U.K. puts its data at the nucleus of post-cookie push for media budgets
News U.K. has overhauled the way it collects, sorts and monetizes its audience data across all its titles via first-party data platform Nucleus.
Here’s why the loss of the third-party cookie is heading toward a collapse in the middle
In the absence of third-party cookies, marketers will need to work more closely with trusted publishers to reach their audiences. Who will lose out? It is posed for a collapse in the middle.