Media enters the realm of unknown unknowns
Every crisis is an opportunity. Our world’s current travails have given me the opportunity to return to writing. Every week I’m going to provide perspective on how media leaders are adapting to a world turned upside down. Please email me with thoughts.
In February 2002, in the wake of the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, chaos reigned and then-Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld was pelted with questions about when the military would find the weapons of mass destruction that served as the pretext for the war. Rumsfeld’s famous response is worth recalling now: “There are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns—the ones we don’t know we don’t know.”
In conversations with several media executives in the past 10 days, we are now firmly in the grip of the known unknowns and unknown unknowns. The known knowns are many. This virus will disrupt business horribly — “9/11 plus the financial crisis, times two,” is how Publicis Groupe veteran Rishad Tobaccowala put it to our Lara O’Reilly — and stretch on for months. Some publishers are more exposed than others, but most I’ve spoken to are preparing for a 30% drop in forecasted revenue.
That will require painful cuts, possibly starting next week en masse. Many publishers, one CEO told me, are waiting for others to go first. “Nobody wants the bad headlines,” this exec said. But everyone has spent the past 10 days, if not more, doing scenario planning in grim spreadsheets. Media businesses are people businesses, and cash intensive ones at that. There are few “levers” to pull on reducing expenses that do not lead to payroll. Expect across the board pay cuts at many publishers, with top executives taking (ideally) the biggest whack. Kudos to BuzzFeed CEO Jonah Peretti for taking no salary while reducing most employees’ compensation. The just-passed stimulus package also includes a provision for furloughing workers that gives publishers a path to softening the blow to affected workers. The cuts will run deep at many publishers.
“I’d rather be too aggressive,” one CEO told me. “The recovery is going to take time. The first dollars to get cut are ad dollars and the last to come back are ad dollars.”
Another known known is this crisis, like all crises, will ruthlessly expose the weak. The “small is beautiful” mantra doesn’t hold up when you only have cash flow to stay in business for a couple of months. One large publisher executive expressed relief at being able to mostly wait out the downturn with painful cuts but without facing an existential crisis. Many aren’t so lucky. Media company balance sheets aren’t typically stuffed with cash and have high fixed costs. What’s more, onerous payment terms will make a comeback. If advertisers are paying after 70 days, that will balloon to 180 days, a CEO told me. Publishers stuffed with debt will struggle to keep up with payments. There will be companies that cease — and more quickly than might be imagined.
Beyond that are the known unknowns. The biggest of which is simply what course this dual crisis will take in the U.S. and western economies. The challenge here is twofold. We face a generational health crisis on top of a generational financial and business crisis. The idea of choosing to focus on one versus the other, no matter what the President says, is ludicrous. The executives I’ve spoken to know we don’t know the course this will take. The most hopeful case, which was laid out on a podcast I recorded earlier this week with GroupM forecaster Brian Wieser, is China’s course. It is showing signs of recovery on both fronts — health and business — that would have been unthinkable a month ago. “We’re even starting to see IOs [insertion orders] there,” a global publisher told me.
Of course, there is also a scenario of Italy, which has struggled to “flatten the curve” although it is showing some signs of progress. The Italian economy remains, for all intents and purposes, chiuso. “Europe is a shitshow,” an executive told me. Without a functioning economy, and even an inkling of knowing when we will have one, publishers need to accept the unknowns and plan for all possibilities. “The real unknown is how long it lasts and how long the bounceback takes,” a publisher said.
One last known unknown I have heard repeatedly: How younger managers and workers will handle this crisis. Leave aside the tired millennial stereotypes. Many of the managers navigating this challenge simply have never worked in a crisis. They didn’t experience the dislocation of 9/11 because they were in elementary school. During the financial crisis, they were in high school or college. For all the ennui over work, many of these younger workers haven’t felt the blows of a crisis. “Our front line managers are rookies at managing through hard times,” one exec told me. One CEO told me he’s mandated directors hold full video conference team meetings at the start of the end of day “just to be able to look at people and make sure they don’t fall apart.” Add on the added degree of difficulty of doing this all remotely.
Finally, there are the unknown unknowns. The past few weeks have been a crash course in these. For all the 2020 predictions posts, nobody wrote “A global pandemic will threaten to wipe out millions, shut much of the world in their homes and threaten another Great Depression.” (Who would have thought we’d all be doing webinars?) After the shock, there is a sense of vulnerability that comes from having your world turned upside down. I sense that in many of my conversations with top executives. The worst reaction would be apathy, but ideally, the best is the forced humility of recognizing there are larger forces you cannot possibly control or even influence but the resolve to adapt no matter what to fight another day.
Cheat sheet: Twitter’s acquisition of Revue heats up the battle of the inbox
The acquisition of Revue shows newsletter platforms will have to continue to ratchet up their efforts to deliver value to authors.
Member ExclusiveDigiday Research: The coronavirus pandemic left marks on publishers’ 2021 revenue plans
While publishers remain focused on direct-sold ads and subscriptions, they seem less focused on diversifying revenue in 2021.
‘We had to take full ownership of data’: Why Denmark’s biggest news site cut reliance on Google’s tech
Denmark’s biggest news site Ekstra Bladet pushes ahead with its investment in first-party data with a homegrown sub for Google Analytics.
SponsoredWhat a content hub can do for marketing teams
In a truly effective marketing team, each team member is aligned, using shared tools and processes to efficiently create, collaborate and connect with their customers. With a content hub, marketers can break down the silos that have traditionally held them back, increasing collaboration in the crucial planning and workflow stages. Implementing this technology will make […]
WTF is FLEDGE?
FLEDGE stands for 'First Locally-Executed Decision over Groups Experiment' and makes ad auction decisions in the browser, rather than at ad server level.
The New York Times’ Ben Smith saw the alt-right’s rise and sees a new era for social platforms
In the latest episode of the Digiday Podcast, the Times media columnist and former BuzzFeed editor-in-chief discusses misinformation on social platforms and why BuzzFeed didn’t make a big subscription push.