Best of the week: Publishers’ ad revenue woes heighten as platforms move to police ads

ad attribution

Our top stories this week delve into Breitbart’s slide and fresh fears regarding tech giants. As always, a full list of these articles appears at the bottom.

Breitbart tumbles …
After the U.S. presidential election, Breitbart was plotting an expansion to spread far-right, populist views in Europe. But today, Breitbart faces traffic declines, advertiser blacklists, campaigns for marketers to steer clear and even a petition within Amazon for it to stop providing ad services.

Key numbers:

  • Breitbart featured 26 brands in May, down from a high of 242 in March. (source: MediaRadar)
  • From January to March, Breitbart had 20 categories of advertisers, many from media/entertainment and retail. This dwindled by April to mostly targeted, conservative brands buying programmatically. (source: MediaRadar)
  • Breitbart had 10.8 million uniques in April, down 13 percent from last year. But many news sites peaked after Donald Trump’s inauguration and have seen audience decline since; Breitbart ranked 67th among news/information sites in April, compared to 62nd a year ago. (source: comScore)

… while other publishers worry about ad revenue
More details have emerged about Google’s plans to filter out invasive ads, and Apple announced an update to its Safari browser would block autoplay video and end the tracking of people’s online browsing.

Consumers, driven by annoying and repetitive ads and privacy concerns to install ad blockers in growing numbers, should benefit from these moves. But publishers are concerned, seeing two tech giants trying to protect their market share — Apple by positioning itself as the guardian of customer privacy and Google by trying to consume as much of the digital advertising pie from rival Facebook.

“Companies that have a vested interest in controlling the consumer experience should not be setting industry policy,” said a publishing executive, speaking anonymously, for fear of upsetting a platform partner. “The doomsday scenario is, it could lead to ad formats that favor the oligopoly.

All eyes on Amazon
Ad buyers, brands, telecom companies and media owners are uneasily watching Amazon, believing the online behemoth could change the duopoly into a triopoly.

“[Telcom companies] now face intense competition from technology giants, such as Amazon and Google, which operate at an entirely different level,” WPP CEO Martin Sorrell said. It’s why Amazon, for Vodafone CEO Vittorio Colao, is the “one to watch.”

Colao said Amazon has the “money, the shareholders, the data and the investment allowing [it] to do everything,” whether that’s producing content, providing OTT services, opening brick-and-mortar bookstores or even, according to Forrester analyst Collin Colburn, taking over search — a market Google almost wholly controls.

Retailers are troubled by what they describe as a two-way relationship with Amazon.

“They buy from us, but they want to sell advertising to us as well,” said one brand marketer. “When you talk to them, you don’t know what their interest is.”

Interesting takes elsewhere:

This week’s top Digiday stories:

More in Media

There is a new definition for MFAs, but it’s meant to be open to interpretation

A new definition for MFAs is available but the vague nature of the guidelines is leading to a lack of standards that might prevent adoption.

Publishers weigh generative AI’s pros and cons during the Digiday Publishing Summit

The publishers who attended DPS were focused on the potential upsides of applying the technology to their operations while guarding against the downsides.

ChatGPT’s latest update fuels publishers’ concerns about AI chatbots siphoning traffic

Now that ChatGPT users can surf the internet for information, some publishers are reconsidering the weight of the issue.