Seven passes left to attend the Digiday Publishing Summit
There’s an irony that the communications business has a communication problem. A chief complaint often heard from ad sellers is ad buyers are remote, mercurial and slow to respond, if they’re heard from at all. It was a thread in our recent “Confessions” series article with an ad sales executive.
Digiday decided to poll ad sellers with the help of SellerCrowd, a Q&A platform for the ad-sales community. SellerCrowd used the LinkedIn API to validate members, so we can be sure the respondents are actually sellers of digital media. The question posed to them was: “What percentage of your RFP submission receive no response?” The results from 214 respondents showed 65 percent of ad sellers don’t hear back more than half the time when they answer requests for proposals. Only 14 percent answered, “I usually get responses.”
The RFP is a hallowed (maybe that should be hated) part of the ad-sales process. Agencies issue them to a wide range of publishers when putting together a plan. The first step to getting on a plan is getting an RFP. The problem: Ad sellers never get feedback on why they didn’t get on the plan.
“It’s a big problem because it only exacerbates the visibility issue,” said Randy Kilgore, chief revenue officer at Tremor Video. “Not only do people not plan digital far ahead, but without feedback, each month can be a crapshoot.”
Kilgore is a sales veteran, having held down top positions at ESPN and The Wall Street Journal. He’s not being nostalgic for the olden days. For him, the issue is structural and inevitable. Agencies pile on work to media planners in too short of a time period. The RFP process is a blunt instrument. But he also isn’t ready to just blame one side.
“Sellers are to blame, too,” he noted. “The proliferation of people trying to generate ad sales is over the top. So many are scrapping for dollars. Getting an RFP is a way to show your manager you’re doing something. So sellers sometimes push too hard just to get that RFP even when they probably don’t deserve it.”
More in Media
More money is flowing into creator marketing — just not directly to creators
Creators’ strategy regarding holiday marketing spending has shifted significantly, according to Collective Voice’s Holiday 2025 Creator Commerce Report. Sponsored content, once the lifeblood of creators’ brand revenue, is no longer the centerpiece, with 70 percent of creators saying traditional sponsored posts will make up less than a quarter of their holiday content.
Fortnite advertising friction: creators say brands are wasting money on custom maps
As ad dollars pour into Fortnite, creators warn that advertisers may be overspending. Five Fortnite creators and talent managers told Digiday that they believe brands are overspending on the platform by focusing their efforts on custom-branded maps, rather than integrations into pre-existing popular experiences.
Overheard during the Digiday publisher town hall
Revenue optimization, dealing with DSPs and SSPs and AI were top of mind for publishers during Digiday’s virtual town hall event.