‘There’s a degree of assumption’: Subway tests addressable media plans using non-addressable data

The header image features an illustration of hands raised in the air while holding money.

Less is more when it comes to the attempt from fast food franchise Subway to reshape media spending around the contours of privacy. Its marketers are trying to build an addressable media strategy using non-addressable data.

It’s the path of least resistance against the likes of Apple and Google, which are cracking down on the amount of personal information companies profit from without obtaining an individual’s consent.

So rather than relying on identifiers to track the minutiae of how people behave online, whether that’s in a browser or in-app, the restaurant chain is looking at alternatives, from contextual to telco data, in partnership with agency Mediacom Scotland.

Some of that data will come from companies like Skyrise Intelligence. The media planning tool has partnerships with several telecoms companies, with access to data signals from 20 million handsets across the U.K., according to the firm. Those signals are then anonymized into segments across iOS and Android devices for the likes of Subway to buy.

A year ago, the advertiser tested some of those segments as a way to run campaigns during the first lockdown. It worked as there was a 52% jump in awareness among those who saw the programmatic ads compared to those who did not.

The test also served as a template for how future campaigns might run once its marketers have limited access to mobile identifiers on Apple devices and no access to third-party cookies in Google’s Chrome browser. But with both mobile identifiers and third-party cookies still in abundance for now, there’s a short window for Subway to compare how ads bought with them perform before they are squeezed out of the market.

“The aim is to figure out how we can serve our guests with the right message at the right time but using less or maybe smarter data, whether that’s non-personally identifiable information or using contextual targeting,” said Angelina Gosal, Subway’s head of marketing in the U.K. and Ireland.

Since the first batch of tests, Subway has run other campaigns that track core parameters from the teleco data including: a device’s proximity to a store, whether its using either food delivery services like Deliveroo, Just Eat or Uber Eats and the time of day when certain promotional offers were used. From there, it gathers insights around how those audiences behave and buys ads against them to see how well they perform. Some tests, which are conducted via the advertiser’s programmatic team at MiQ, have focused on buying certain audiences in certain areas where there’s a promotional offer running, for example.

The challenge is that data like this isn’t always accurate as a result of how its been procured. Even when it is, it can be costly to obtain.

“There’s a degree of assumption here, but when it comes to the accuracy of the data, its important that we verify it with other data we get either internally or from other trusted partners like other media vendors in and around our stores,” said Gosal. “It’s not necessary the most cost-effective way but it’s still the most accurate way in terms of helping us understand the needs of our guest.”

If these campaigns are successful enough then it could give Subway marketers a clear enough view on mobile users, whether on iOS or Android devices, without flouting the privacy restrictions from Apple and Google, respectively.

Subway is already working with GumGum, an ad tech company that specializes in contextual advertising, and is planning to broker deals, with publishers directly or via the Ozone alliance so it can run more contextual campaigns.

Other advertisers are making similar moves.

Eventually, Subway wants to have many of its spending decisions be informed by non-personal data. The hope is that it could connect data from Skyrise, for example, with data from an out-of-home media owner or even from connected TV to get a clearer picture of what people go on to do after seeing its ads over a certain period of time.

“Every advertiser we work with is strategically committed to figuring out context for their business,” said Raman Sidhu, chief revenue officer at analytics platform Beemray. “It’s priority number one. The paradigm shift is opening up real advertising innovation.”

More in Marketing

TikTok ad execs are finally talking — just enough to keep Q4 intact

While the U.S. waits for China to sign off on its proposed TikTok deal, platform execs have reassured marketers no changers are coming in Q4.

‘We were getting crushed’: Brands cut back on free online returns to offset tariff costs

Some brands are even eliminating the perk altogether as they try to mitigate the steep costs of the Trump tariffs.

Media agency performance analysis

The Rundown: OpenAI’s ChatGPT Atlas browser aims to turn the internet into a conversation

What marketers need to know about what to expect when the internet becomes chat.