Sometimes creatives don’t need to ‘think different’
Mark Duffy has written the Copyranter blog for 11 years and is a freelancing copywriter with 25-plus years of experience. His hockey wrist shot is better than yours.
In 1997, Apple launched its iconic “Think Different” campaign. Advertising creatives loved the campaign for a few reasons: It boldly didn’t show any product and made the Mac customer the hero (most ad creatives didn’t use PCs). Copywriters and art directors ended up adopting the tagline as a mantra for what they did (or hoped to do) day-in and day-out.
Creative directors — always looking for a rejection rejoinder that doesn’t crush their underlings’ fragile egos — started using “it’s just not different enough” in lieu of harsher criticisms like “it’s not creative enough” or “it’s too expected” or the always-helpful feedback, “I’ll know it when I see it.”
Anxious ad creatives are often being prodded and pushed to come up with “different,” “never-before-seen” concepts. That’s a shit-ton of pressure, especially if you’re “ideating” in a well-trodden product category. This causes copywriters to deviate from the brief, to abandon the agreed-upon message. It causes art directors to create insane visuals that make absolutely no sense. It causes creatives to hatch puzzling “borrowed interest” ideas that have zero connection to the product. Because always remember: there are “good different” and “bad different” ideas. For instance:
This 30-second spot for Toyo tires by Vitro USA was released early last month. Here’s the borrowed interest logic equation for the ad: If steaks = cars, then spray cheese = non-Toyo tires. O…K., I think steaks can be like tires if they’re well-done (black) and hard to chew (rubbery). But … yeah, this is a prime example of “bad different.”
Maxim’s is a fast-food chain in Hong Kong. This ad, for its boneless Hainan chicken, was released in December. Maxim’s is declaring that its chicken is so tender and “succulent” that it glides smoothly and quickly down a playground slide. Maxim’s then invited people to visit its Facebook page and guess how long it takes a piece of its chicken to slither down the slide.
This “bad different” stunt makes me think that Maxim’s soaked that chicken slice with WD-40. It is not an appetizing image. At all. Agency: STHK, Hong Kong.
Here’s a new campaign via Y&R Argentina for Topline gum. Copy line: “Stretch Your Kisses.” This is a textbook digital art direction example of “just because you can do it, doesn’t mean you should.” Here was (probably) the art director’s thought process: “What if I turned their faces into gum?! (But that doesn’t make sen…) Shut up, left side of brain.” He (The AD on these ads was a man) probably then spent two weeks making the comps.
South America, for years now, has been the undisputed home of WTFH art direction. I’m 99 percent sure the client didn’t approve these “bad different” ads. Previous ads for the brand have been more “good different,” like this 2009 commercial by DCN Saatchi and Saatchi.
What, exactly, makes an ad “good different”? Well, the “different” needs to be tied directly to the brand/product. Also, you just know it when you see it (sorry). A recent example is this Tylenol “Headache Chicken” spot.
What is the best “good different” campaign of all time? Return with me to 1989 and watch a commercial from the “if it’s out there, it’s in here” campaign for the NYNEX Yellow Pages, created by Chiat/Day. (See more of the spots here.)
You giddily looked forward to the next visual pun, to see if you could figure out the punchlines before the end of the spots. This is how you “think different.” This wasn’t just “good different,” it was stupendous different. And nothing like it has been produced since.
‘You’re not going to get it all right’: IBM CMO Michelle Peluso on managing through a crisis
As marketers manage another crisis, they are thinking about how to help their teams as well as how they should be advertising.
‘Stand for something’: As protests continue, tone-deaf influencer marketing is in the spotlight
Questions about diversity in influencer marketing, opportunism and the need for brands to get comfortable with influencers taking a stance on politics and racial issues are bubbling up now as this may be a moment of self-reflection for the influencer marketing community.
‘There isn’t a talent pipeline problem’: Confessions of a black advertising exec
In this edition of our Confessions series, in which we exchange anonymity for candor, we hear from a black media buyer who believes brands need to do more to support for Black Lives Matter and that agencies still haven't truly changed their hiring policies.
SponsoredVideo: Marketers discuss the future state of less interruptive in-stream ads
In a new video, experts from GumGum, The Martin Agency and Pinterest discuss the future of video advertising — and outline their vision for how video ads can be less disruptive.
Member ExclusiveDigiday Research: Over half of brands say they handle marketing ‘mostly’ with internal resources
Digiday’s quarterly benchmarking survey found that about 83% of marketers are managing their marketing either mostly in-house or completely in-house. That's up from the 55% of marketers six months ago who said the same.
Member Exclusive‘Our job is to sell’: Marketers, moving past coronavirus response, return to selling products
Marketers need to get back to the job at hand: Keeping the squeaky wheels of capitalism turning.