Mark Duffy has written the Copyranter blog for 10 years and is a freelancing copywriter with 20-plus years of experience. His hockey wrist shot is better than yours. Follow him on Twitter.
It’s a question I’ve been asked many times over the years by civilians: Just what is it that a creative director does? Sorry, but there is no quick, pat answer, especially nowadays, young millennial. Instead, I will circle the question, like a vulture, hopefully while avoiding defecating on my own legs, unlike a vulture. There will also be scare quotes, many scare quotes.
I know copywriters do the “words,” and art directors do the “pictures,” so does a creative director direct the commercials?
Yeah, as if. Also, your demeaning words-pictures comment makes us already-insecure creatives feel like we’re in kindergarten.
So are the CDs then the big swinging Don Draper dongs that think up all the big ideas?
Ha, no. In the traditional bloated mega-mega agencies, most CDs don’t do much “creative” work. He “guides” and “approves” and “steals” creative.
But most of the time, he is also the one who “sells” the creative to the client. A CD who can sell, who is great presenter — while still not worth his ridiculous salary — is a keeper. You outsiders think you know about this dynamic from watching “Mad Men.” Well, you don’t. The process is, and always has been, more nuanced than what you see via those cartoonish characters. A good CD will sell a creative team’s half-baked ideas as full-baked and sell their insane ideas — thought up maybe while baked — as sane.
At smaller, independent shops, the CDs are, of course, very hands-on; they still create, because the survival of their business depends on it.
Well, you’re only a copywriter, copyranter. I’d like to hear what one of these “hands-on” CDs has to say.
Fine. I’ll ask my former CD boss, Paul Gigante, founding partner of Gigante Vaz Partners in New York. Here’s how he describes WTF he does:
“A creative director is an intuitive and charming interloper, who has not only mastered the ability to distinguish the good ideas from the bad ones that are conjured between his or her own ears but also between the ears of others under his rule. Further, the job requires the ability to inspire others to greatness, fight off the ceaseless entreaties of those in his own ranks who lack the guts to embrace something new and brilliant, and to sell good ideas, with verve and panache, to people who might not otherwise know the difference.”
“Interloper.” LOL. I worked for Gigante for many years and learned to trust his intuition; I rarely disagreed with him. And I am a professional boldface asshole of a disagreer.
But I have a friend who’s only 26 and he’s a “creative director,” and he doesn’t do any of those things.
Yes, the “old-school” CD is waning, quickly, quicker than the old-school CDs want to admit. There are now so many more people in the field who call themselves “creative director” than there were last century. You got your: digital CDs; social media CDs; “content” CDs; “native” CDs; “marketing” CDs (God help us); and, yes, lots and lots of young CDs at publisher creative studios who are “creative directors” by title only, kids who have no training and no business being in the discipline of advertising creativity.
I still really don’t get it. I’m going to go online and look for an answer.
I’ve already done that for you: Here is the inevitable “Shit Creative Directors Say” video. You can scroll through 19 pages of the Creative Director Meme on quick meme. According to the badly written Wikipedia entry, an advertising CD “is determined to develop various marketing schemes and strategies for a company or client that he or she is hired by.” This stock photo guy is the first “creative director” image result on Google. A CD often is the biggest creative department douchebag. Lastly, I met and briefly interviewed BBDO’s David Lubars in 2007. He is a very proud and very serious man.
So, WTF is a creative director?
Unfortunately, the overwhelming, defining characteristic is still exactly like it is on “Mad Men”: He is a White Male.
Marketing Briefing: U.S. marketers prepare contingency plans amid potential TikTok ban
The likelihood of a ban is still up in the air, marketers and agency execs say, which is why some are simply taking a wait and see approach while others are preparing contingency plans.
In graphic detail: Gamers are warming up to in-game ads
Comscore questioned gamers about their attitudes toward advertisements in games for its State of Gaming report. Digiday got a sneak peek.
Digiday+ Research deep dive: Agency spending on TikTok plateaus as brands struggle with what to make of the app
Agency clients' spending on TikTok may have hit a plateau, while brand marketers are still searching for the right answer when it comes to how much confidence they should have in the platform.
SponsoredBrands are optimizing video production to drive user acquisition
Sponsored by QuickFrame by MNTN With brands increasingly investing in video ads on social media, marketers are enhancing their video production capabilities to unlock growth on Facebook and Instagram. Especially urgent in an uncertain economic climate, brands must minimize production costs while creating a high enough volume of social media videos to identify the creative […]
Meta, Snapchat, Twitter layoffs spell trouble for agency relationships
The speed and scale of platform layoffs only compound the problem of marketers feeling neglected by the social media giants.
Lessons from marketers’ experience with generative AI
Enthralled as marketers clearly are with the possibilities of AI, they’re starting to think they might need a strategy for it.