Confessions of a social agency exec: Clients still want to ‘go viral’
All good things must end. The free lunch that was organic reach on social platforms is over. Now, brands looking to grow an audience on these three news feeds are told they must pay to play.
In the latest edition of our Confessions series, where we exchange anonymity for candor, one social media agency executive in the U.K. said the cold, hard truth still hasn’t sunk in for many brands. Clients instead are still under the spell of organic reach, despite the headlines proclaiming the phenomenon dead various times over. Responses have been lightly edited for clarity.
You’ve said that clients are still obsessed with organic reach. Please explain.
Until two years ago, organic reach was achievable; it was what good social media was. Content was created for its merits, and the rest would take care of itself naturally. But with the algorithm changes, that rarely happens now. Brands haven’t yet adjusted. They say they have, but when they come to us, they’ll ask to “go viral” a couple of times a month. There’s no recipe to go viral, and that’s not a sustainable approach, not anymore.
So they’re reluctant to pay?
Yes. Everyone in the industry knows reach is not free anymore, but the client mindset is a couple of years behind. They see paying agencies like us as their entire content-creation budget, which makes it hard to say, “That thing you used to get for free, you need to pay extra for that.” There’s nothing wrong with posting some organic content; you need it to sustain your community. However, when growing your audience, there’s no value putting out content if no one sees it, and hardly anyone will see it without ad spend.
Where does this reluctance come from?
Well, you can’t tell when a video has been paid to be promoted, so many clients who see viral work will assume money hasn’t been spent. They think it is still possible to go viral, but that’s very rare. For every Ice Bucket Challenge, there are millions of stunts without traction at all.
What are some of the problems with excluding paid media from the creative process?
Content made for organic reach is talking to people who already know you. You don’t have to introduce yourself as you already have a relationship with the audience. For paid content, you need to assume there’s less knowledge about the brand. Currently, brands are creating a funny video but not thinking about where it’s going to be seen. They’re still creating content and then later down the line thinking about how they are going to distribute it. It’s doing half a job. Distribution should be at the forefront of the creative process. If we’re creating this content and no one is seeing it, the client is not getting enough out of us either. Also, it isn’t giving our work the best chance.
How does that affect agencies?
It’s not going to work to have one agency for content and another for distribution. Often the creative and paid social agencies on the client’s brief are competing against each other. They don’t have same strategy. We’ve had experiences where we’re fulfilling different objectives to the paid social agency. It’s a bad way to do it.
Digiday+ Research deep dive: YouTube holds strong as a reliable marketing channel for agencies and brands
YouTube might not be considered the most exciting marketing channel out there, but brands and agencies see the platform as a reliable marketing channel that delivers consistent success.
Pringles goes all in on social to put college athletes front-and-center for ‘March Mustache’ campaign
Pringles is turning to social media — particularly Instagram — to leverage some of the college athletes playing in the March Madness basketball tournament, with the goal of reaching college basketball fans on second screens.
Short-form video needs better monetization, creator funds aren’t the way to do it
Creator funds have almost been like a stepping stone before a more permanent solution is either considered or put into place.
SponsoredHow advertisers are leveraging omnichannel attribution and measurement to power CTV
Sponsored by MNTN Connected TV advertising has joined and expanded the larger ecosystem of campaigns that advertisers deploy. As such, omnichannel marketing strategies now encompass television and mobile devices, tablets and other screens such as out-of-home. And as customers engage across these different touchpoints, brands are seeking and moving their measurement and analytics efforts to […]
L’Oreal uses social listening, in-house teams to tap into beauty trends ‘at the speed of culture’
The beauty behemoth is turning to in-house teams to accelerate content production that taps into trends within days, rather than the weeks or months of traditional marketing and advertising timelines.
With Canva and Adobe’s new updates, the generative AI race enters the brand design space
Canva and Adobe are just two of several major design and visual platforms that are rapidly introducing new generative AI capabilities in the service of brands.