What goes up must come down.
Just this week, Facebook said it was “refocusing” its use of AI after its bots hit a failure rate of 70 percent, meaning bots could only get to 30 percent of requests without some sort of human intervention.
Many brands had already begun dropping their bots, saying that they didn’t do what they were supposed to. Fashion retailer Everlane, which was one of the first Facebook Messenger partners, announced last week it would no longer use it, saying they would rather stick with email. For another conversational commerce pioneer, Spring, customers have found that the bot, based on Facebook Messenger, is hard to use and doesn’t have the level of personalization people expect.
“Bots that we are proposing for clients and customers are based on making sure we’re identifying a true need,” said Pam Scheideler, chief digital officer at Deutsch L.A. Scheideler and her team built a TacoBot for Taco Bell, which she cited as a good example of solving for a true need — group orders from the restaurant.
“We’ve begun to filter out and ask when is the right time to propose a bot, although clients are still pretty interesting.”
It’s not surprising that bots are experiencing a backlash. Like branded emoji keyboards before them, there was a gold rush toward the new tech. Taco Bell’s TacoBot let you order from your Slack messenger, Domino’s DOM helped users order from Facebook. At whole Foods, you could chat with the Messenger bot to get a recipe, while HP’s print bot printed things for you, via Facebook Messenger. Brands went to them because they were easy to build from a basic perspective. But while Facebook Messenger seems to be stalling, brands and agencies are starting to get cautious about bots and other doodads on other platforms too.
One sticking point is that bots are opt-in experiences. And for customers to opt into something that requires a new behavior plus a lot of information about them, they want the payoff to be pretty great. Users expect personalized, human-like assistance from bots — and that’s where they fail, at least for now.
And for sensitive situations that need a human input, bots don’t work.
“I would call it overpromising,” said CP+B executive creative tech director Joe Corr. “Brands that created bots with a structured request or utility like Domino’s or in retail were easy. But bots that tried to break out of the utility and be chatbots became the problem.”
Back in August, VC attention to the space seemed to have exploded. According to data provided by CBInsights, just in July, seven bot-focused startups raised first funding rounds. And CBInsights also made a running list of — as far as they knew — 51 corporate chatbots in travel, retail and insurance. People built them because it sounded cool to add “bot” to everything, said Scheideler. “Made us feel futuristic.”
The media side of the industry also invested heavily in chatbots, with publishers like CNN and Mic creating bots for breaking news, or in the case of Mic’s, to make conversation with readers. And as Digiday previously reported, while in the media business bots may be the future, they’re not the present, with publishers finding the results of integrating content onto Messenger or Kik kind of underwhelming.
Another problem is clients often think bots are the only way to get into machine learning or AI, both “hot” new technologies, according to Scheideler. For example a brand could use AI for a better product search on a website — no bot necessary. “There is a lot of confusion across the board,” said Scheideler. Martin Legowiecki, creative technology director at Deutsch agreed, saying that building a bot is complicated. For example, look at the myriad of ways a Slackbot decides whether to send a message: This Westworld-style flow chart reflects the kind of multi-level decision-making that goes into play when making a bot.
Then there is the question of whether the bot is about marketing or core business, said Corr, who argued that things like Domino’s or Taco Bell were about business and utility, not marketing.
And especially in Facebook, whose bot offering seems to have stalled with a failure rate, the platform changes to consistently and constantly that agencies and brands are worried about where to go next. And while Facebook may tolerate an uneven experience, brands and agencies won’t.
So for 1-800-Flowers, which offers a bot that lets you order flowers, it works great — but it doesn’t show all the options a website might. Bot tech is not especially advanced yet on natural language processing: Corr said things have improved, but there’s still a way to go. If bots are impressively conversational to start with, humans get too colloquial — and then the bot fails, creating frustration. “You have to think about is as creating a human. If you sort of just go out there, it won’t work.” said Legowiecki. “It’s hard to build an expertise.”
Member ExclusiveMarketing Briefing: ‘This is a better way to travel’: Q&A with Airbnb’s global head of marketing on the company’s new capabilities, in-housing
Digiday caught up with Hiroki Asai to chat about the changes as well as Airbnb’s approach to marketing.
The vast majority of marketers are unhappy with their Customer Data Platforms, but then again, not many are sure what they really are
Marketers are confused by tech vendors', well, marketing as the requirement for complexity grows
How the layoffs at Upcomer show the challenges of public ownership in esports media
Enthusiast’s lack of a seemingly cohesive strategy for Upcomer is a reflection of the broader challenges it faces as a gaming and esports holding company that is, at the moment, one of the few publicly traded firms in the industry.
SponsoredHow marketers and retailers are unlocking the true value of retail media
Ben Kneen, senior director of product management, Xandr It’s a challenging time for retailers in the advertising industry. As they cope with supply chain woes and inflation-related pressures, they seek high-margin revenue streams amid evolving privacy regulations and massive shifts in identity solutions — including IDFA, the deprecation of third-party cookies and more. In light […]
‘A lot of investment and commitment’: Manchester City ramps up esports efforts
Early forays from football teams into esports were conservative to say the least, opting to stay close to football and focus on competitive events for the Fifa football series.
How Blue Apron meal kit is revamping its marketing strategy with digital video
Returning to advertising after two years, DTC Blue Apron is diversifying its media spend with video advertising to boost brand awareness.