Publishers’ candid thoughts on video: ‘We’re a bunch of sheep’
The pivot to video has cooled, but many publishers are still focused on video — and that means figuring out what platforms are best for what roles.
At closed-door sessions at the Digiday Video Summit in Scottsdale, Arizona, on May 21, publishers gave their candid feedback on the issues they’re facing, from how to make money off Facebook to the roles YouTube, Amazon, Netflix and, yes, Twitter should play in video-distribution strategies.
No longer Facebook’s fool
“We haven’t been focusing on Facebook for a long time in terms of video. We know what their audience behavior is. We said to them early on, ‘You actually don’t care about 360 video; you actually don’t care about Facebook Live.’ They tried to persuade us for a little while; then, they said, ‘You’re right.’”
“We have three brands that we developed specifically for social. What’s interesting is that they do extremely well on social, but when we try to showcase those on our [owned and operated sites], they do not resonate at all. It’s frustrating because they don’t make a ton of money on Facebook.”
“Facebook cares about Facebook’s business — and they have made that abundantly clear over the years if you bothered to listen.”
YouTube is reliable … to a point
“YouTube is quite clearly a video platform, so it’s easier for a video to be optimized and do well. Facebook has never been like that.”
“YouTube is reliable. The revenue responds to the levers as you pull them, and there’s something comforting and nice about that.”
“There are a ton of things you can learn by putting a video on YouTube. You can see retention graphs. You can learn where the drop-off is. We’ve implemented product changes based on YouTube.”
“We’ve made changes based on user behavior we’ve seen on YouTube because what’s successful on YouTube is also successful on our site.”
“Everyone’s talking about going to YouTube. But you can’t build a business on YouTube, either. If you’re a PewDiePie and you have fans, sure, you can make a few million dollars and be comfortable. But if you’re trying to build a big media business? The margins and the $2 CPMs are not going to cut it.”
Twitter is a friend (or less a foe)
“Twitter is a breath of fresh air in that they do want to work with you more than Facebook.”
“Twitter, right now in marketplace, is more amenable and thoughtful in conversations with publishers.”
“The revenue side seems like a positive story. I have doubts that most views are desktop.”
“They refuse to report time spent on the program.”
A show on Netflix can be lost in the Amazon
“If Netflix improved its algorithm, we’d actually see things instead of the 15 things they’re promoting this month.”
“At the end of the day, even if you do sign that Netflix deal, you may not get discovered.”
Amazon’s opportunity isn’t lost on the company
“Amazon has been very keen in trying to make deals that are favorable because of deals others are trying to make. They’ve been really amenable to creating terms that are different. It’s not take it or leave it. They understand if they piss on publishers long enough, they’re going to diversify.”
“Churn is actually pretty good on Amazon. It’s lower than direct-to-consumer OTT. It’s bundled with Prime, so it’s pretty significantly lower — at least 25 percent lower.”
“It’s a vanity play at this point. You’re not going to make any money. But you can say we have this OTT channel.”
Where do people want to watch videos?
“People don’t go to websites to watch video. They don’t go to Facebook to watch video. They go to YouTube.”
“We’re on the autoplay crack. Being a print publisher to begin with, people come to our properties to read stories, so we give them an autoplay video.”
“Isn’t that the case for most videos on Facebook, too? Aren’t people there to see words?”
Whose show is it anyway?
“If the terms are decent and the concept makes sense, sure, we’ll do a deal. But if they’re going to own 100 percent of [intellectual property] that’s going to be valuable to us, no.”
“Owning IP isn’t always so clear. When Malcolm Gladwell writes an article for Condé Nast, they don’t necessarily own it. They may own parts of it.”
“What’s the big thing now? Making original content for OTT platforms? IP? We’re just a bunch of fucking sheep falling over the cliff repeatedly.”
For more on the modernization of the video and entertainment business, subscribe to our weekly video briefing email.
Member ExclusiveFuture of TV Briefing: 5 takeaways from this year’s TV upfront market
The Future of TV Briefing this week recaps the top trends from this year's TV advertising upfront negotiations and what they portend for the next year.
Member ExclusiveFuture of TV Briefing: The free, ad-supported streaming TV market has come of age
The Future of TV Briefing this week looks at how the free, ad-supported streaming TV market has entered a new era in its maturation.
Four years after its premiere, NBC News’ ‘Stay Tuned’ has stayed the course on Snapchat
The twice-daily news show averages nearly 1 million unique viewers per episode, and 50% of its audience tunes in at least three times per week.
SponsoredHow the ad industry can use its borrowed time to future-proof first-party data solutions
Trent Lloyd, co-founder and head of brand solutions, Eyeota Google’s updated timeline for its Privacy Sandbox rollout, including its two-year delay of third-party cookie deprecation on Chrome, didn’t come as a surprise to many industry observers, given the limited utility of Google’s FLoC and the slow momentum of the Privacy Sandbox in the World Wide […]
Member ExclusiveFuture of TV Briefing: How Amazon, Roku and YouTube stepped up in this year’s upfront market
The Future of TV Briefing this week looks at how the competitive playing field between Amazon, Roku and YouTube versus traditional TV network owners for advertisers' dollars changed in this year's upfront market.
All Def owner Culture Genesis snags $5M in revenue after gaining YouTube ad sales rights
The digital studio claims to be the first Black-owned media company to have secured the ability to sell its YouTube channels’ inventory directly to advertisers.