The trend for many publishers is to loudly declare they are “mobile-first.” But the reality is, well, more complicated.
Most mobile-first proponents loudly trumpet exploding mobile audiences. That’s true. Just about every publisher today is seeing an increasing amount of their traffic coming from mobile devices — often over 50 percent of their overall, in the case of sites like BuzzFeed, Glamour and CNN. Yet it’s not a zero-sum game: Most publishers are seeing their desktop audiences grow, too, albeit at a much slower rate than mobile.
According to publisher analytics service Chartbeat, mobile consumption is, on the whole, complementing desktop. Desktop traffic is essentially daytime traffic: It starts to increase at 9 a.m., peaks at noon and starts to decline at 6 p.m. Mobile, in contrast, tends to decline in the early morning and peak in the evening. Put in more concrete terms, people are reading on their desktops while at work and shifting to tablets and smartphones while at home.
There’s no doubt that many publishers are seeing surges in mobile traffic, but right now, they’re not all seeing corresponding declines. Data from comScore shows that while mobile traffic to the Web’s top 10 news/information properties grew 36 percent in the US last year, overall desktop traffic for those sites decreased by just 1 percent. Mobile consumption may be eating into desktop habits, but, so far, it’s doing so slowly.
“In general, it seems like each medium is strong while the others are weak,” said Josh Schwartz, chief data scientist at Chartbeat. “People are using phones while they wouldn’t be using desktops anyway,” he said.
The problem with the mobile-first narrative, however, is that it downplays these sorts of nuances in favor of looking at the pure percentage numbers. This, in turn, changes how publishers view both the design and content strategies of their sites.
Consider sites like Mic, SI.com and Time.com, which in the name of responsive design, all feature desktop sites that feel like blown-up versions of their mobile sites, hamburger menus and all. This is the exact inverse of publishers’ traditional approach to mobile, wherein they shrunk their existing desktop sites for smaller screens.
“Those experiences tend to be unusable, confusing and lacking a real strategy,” said Dan Maccarone, CEO of Charming Robot. “Companies that take that approach are chasing a trend that they aren’t fully wrapping their heads around,” he said.
Maccarone said that the problem with the mobile-first approach is that publishers have primarily viewed it as an design and interface problem, not a user-experience one. Readers on mobile aren’t just consuming content on smaller screens, they’re doing so on-the-go, a use case that imposes a new set of needs that publishers have, on the whole, been slow to address.
“If you think of mobile not as a small screen but as the seventh form of mass media, then the differences between it and the PC are like the differences between radio and print,” said Luke Wroblewski, CEO of app developer Input Factory. “Mobile is the biggest, highest potential form of mass media out there. Everyone’s just treating it like a smaller version of the thing that came before it.”
Dentsu’s podcast celebrating Black empowerment tries to do its part to fill the advertising inequity gap
The Dentsu-backed More Than That with Gia Peppers kicked off season 3 last week, featuring several major advertisers (and Dentsu clients) including Procter & Gamble, General Motors, Kroger and Mastercard.
The Athletic’s Sebastian Tomich is looking beyond ads and subscriptions to reach profitability
The Athletic's path to profitability is set for 2025, and to achieve this goal, chief commercial officer Sebastian Tomich is focused on more than just selling ads directly to prospective advertisers.
How newsroom unions intervene when members get laid off
Amid the recent wave of media layoffs, here are some of the ways newsroom unions are intervening.
SponsoredAdvertising predictions that will shake up the media industry in 2023
Chris Kelly, CEO, Upwave Like many people, marketers and advertisers were ready to see 2022 come to a close. A year that started off promising was assailed by inflation, layoffs and the disastrous effects of RSV, the flu and additional COVID strains. Still, despite an uncertain outlook for 2023, there are plenty of reasons for […]
Despite Q1’s slow start, publishers are bullish about events revenue for 2023
Publishers like BDG and Apartment Therapy are banking on events revenue to give them a leg up in 2023.
Media Briefing: The case for and against monthly and annual subscriptions in the battle for retention
There are no one-size-fits-all solutions for improving retention in a subscriptions business. While annual subscribers might stick around longer for some, other publishers will have better luck with monthly plans.