Upworthy goes clickbait-free: ‘We were never about the headlines’
Viral content site Upworthy burst onto the scene in 2012 with its infectious formula of aggregated feel-good stories with ultra-clickable headlines. Now, after being subject to both loathing from media observers and an entire economy of copycats aping its tactics, Upworthy is making a pivot away from curation and toward quality original fare.
The effort, says founder Eli Pariser, is a natural evolution for Upworthy, which has used its curation chops to build insights about what readers respond to. The plan now is to put that to use with original longform stories, such as its lengthy look at the ethics of fast food, and even original video. The effort is spearheaded by New York Times alum Amy O’Leary, who joined in February. The moves come as Upworthy’s traffic has essentially flatlined. It got 13.3 million unique visitors in May, according to comScore, down precipitously from nearly 29 million last summer.
Pariser spoke to Digiday about the site’s new direction. A lightly edited transcript below.
You guys pioneered a gushing headline format that became widely imitated and, ultimately, mocked. You ever feel bad about that?
Peter Koechley, our co-founder, recently said something along those lines. We started messing with headlines as an experiment to draw attention to videos about domestic violence and climate change. Then we saw the formula replicated. On the one hand it’s fun to be on the bleeding edge but on other hand we’ve never really been about headlines. It was in service of an end.
But that’s all most people saw.
Those headlines alone are not enough to drive a huge amount of viral traffic. If they were you would see every media company growing the way we had. The other critical part is the content you’re delivering has to be what people want to share in large numbers. It’s not just headlines, but also the number of likes and comments. You’re telling stories that move people.
So what’s changing here?
We’re moving away from focusing on the splashy picture frame to the picture within the frame. Our model for this from the beginning was to have a site that wasn’t just replicating and syndicating AP articles or whatever. We wanted to do something where we’re adding value.
That means less curation, and more originals?
Initially we were doing the work to find great stories that only handful of people saw. But we realized that there are some areas where there’s great interest but there aren’t great stories to curate. Find me five great examples of highly shareable content about out fast food workers’ wages. It’s hard. It’s an important topic but not the easiest to get a lot of people to tune into.
So it’s a bit like the Netflix model with House of Cards: Use curation to learn about what people like and use that to make your own stuff.
Right. It’s no accident that one of our original stories has gotten 25 million views already.
Don’t you think that’s kind of icky when it comes to news and these sorts of serious topics?
Not at all. If you’re telling a story around a campfire do you close your eyes or keep them open to see if people are listening or even there? Do you consider their judgement on your ability to tell a story? People aren’t obligated to listen to us. We have to learn from them.
How does all of this change the Upworthy staff? Doesn’t seem like curators always make the best reporters.
Most of our team has been excited to dig into this new direction. We did have some folks who didn’t make that shift. That’s hard, but it means that we have great new people coming on.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: What publishers should watch for when meeting with blockchain vendors
In this week's Media Briefing, media editor Kayleigh Barber explores the primary questions publishers should be asking when evaluating potential blockchain partners.
‘Push back with brilliance’: Jared Belsky explains Acadia’s approach to acquiring other agencies and recruiting clients
Digital agency Acadia is focused squarely on winning mid-sized clients that the holding companies usually pass over or don’t treat seriously enough.
Amid video growing pains, Amazon Live struggles to attract publishers
Amazon wants publishers to drive their audiences toward the ecommerce platform's shoppable videos. Many are skeptical.
SponsoredHow advertisers are shifting mindsets to succeed amid iOS 15 and other identity challenges
On top of the impending cookie deprecation, Apple’s recent iOS 15 changes are causing concern for many advertisers by affecting pixels, IP addresses and email addresses. While these upcoming changes may be concerning for many, shifting mindsets and getting away from a binary way of thinking with solutions being 100% contextual or 100% universal IDs […]
Architectural Digest will publish its first global print issue as part of revamped international rollout strategy
As Condé Nast shifts to a consolidated global content strategy, editorial teams around the world are working more closely at AD to coordinate the publication of feature stories, videos and new franchises.
‘It requires more scrappy thinking’: How cannabis brand Charlotte’s Web approaches media buying and execution
The cannabis industry continues to morph into a legitimate and possibly lucrative vertical for media agencies to pursue, as cannabis brands raise their marketing game to new heights.