‘They’re slowly starting to kill it’: Ad tech execs brace for Apple to scrap in-app ad tracking
Ad tech execs have a new concern that’s moving to the front burners: the specter of Apple extending Safari’s mobile and desktop anti-tracking blocks to Apple’s in-app environment.
There is good reason for the jitters. Apple has taken a no-nonsense approach to third-party ad tracking, blocking all third-party cookies on Safari, putting the kibosh on all programmatic monetization on the Safari browser. Many ad tech vendors see a clear path to this jumping to ads in-app on iOS devices.
Apple has typically been tight-lipped on plans for IDFA, its identifier for advertisers and the only means of targeting an ad, and tracking its attribution, within apps on iOS devices. Earlier this month Apple posted an update for App Store Connect that described how app developers should use IDFA — the only way to offer targeted ads on iOS devices. In the update, Apple stated that app developers must disclose how they’re using IDFA, and ensure it is only for the specific purposes of ad targeting and attribution and nothing else. They must also ensure all third-party partners are doing the same.
Meanwhile, this month Apple also revealed an API for the iOS app ecosystem, SKAdNetork, positioning it as a useful tool to track post-campaign attribution. Some ad tech vendors believe that Apple’s intention is to replace IDFA with SKAdNetork and in doing so appease advertisers that their mobile app attribution won’t tank as a result of pulling IDFA.
“They’re [Apple] slowly starting to kill it,” said Dan Wilson, CEO of London Media Exchange. “This [API update] is a brilliant move from Apple because it’s a way for them to police and control attribution. It will keep it [in-app attribution] within their own proprietary environment.”
For others, if Apple’s plan is to get rid of IDFA and replace it with its own mechanism, there will be repercussions for anyone using yield optimization tools within the iOS ecosystem.
“It makes the Apple ecosystem less attractive to those that monetize it, like publishers and app developers,” said an ad tech executive who spoke on condition of anonymity. “If developers [that rely on in-app ad monetization] start pulling away, what then? Do consumers move to Android where there’s a more vibrant developer ecosystem of apps?”
IDFA has been the only way to target ads within iOS apps to date, and users can control their settings for it. But over the years, it has been abused, according to ad tech executives. IDFA is a way to track iOS users (on an aggregated, not individual, basis) and used by a lot of location and device-graph vendors to assess how a user has interacted with an ad. But typically over the years, shady vendors have been able to access that same data to track, for instance, a user’s location in order to create profiles to monetize the data, according to ad tech sources.
“Many in the industry have concerns around Apple restricting use on IDFA,” said Ari Lewine, co-founder and chief strategy officer of ad exchange Triplelift. “The strange thing is they still support IDFA for in-app targeting which is arguably less private than web cookies.”
The reason for that is that cookies aren’t persistent and can be easily lost or cleared, but the same can’t be said of user data within IDFA. “So in short, Apple’s stance is confusing. Why restrict something on mobile web you allow for in-app?” he added.
Digiday contacted Apple but received no response by the time of this article’s publication.
Publishers invest in more crypto reporters
Publishers like Bloomberg, Forbes, Fortune, Gizmodo and Money are investing in more reporters to cover cryptocurrencies and the blockchain.
Vox Media’s Ryan Pauley explains how expanding the CRO role beyond ad sales improves ad sales
In March, Vox Media expanded the purview of Pauley’s role beyond ad sales to also encompass consumer revenue, affiliate and commerce businesses.
The Rundown: Travel, entertainment ad spend expected to remain strong in 2022, while early pandemic trends drop off
Sectors that took off earlier in the pandemic are seeing a slowdown in advertising spend as companies face a possible recession.
SponsoredConsumers expect brands to be authentic in their DE&I commitments
Sponsored by Amazon Ads With consumers looking to brands to take stances on global and social issues that impact their lives, it’s hard to argue the important role brands play in our society. With this great opportunity also comes great responsibility, and consumers are paying attention. New research commissioned by Amazon Ads with Environics Research […]
Digiday DealBook: New NFL streaming service, Instagram shuts down e-commerce site, HBO Max and Discovery+ streaming merger, and more
Facebook and Instagram will halt its live shopping feature of affiliate sites on August 31. This announcement comes after shaky Q2 earnings.
Una agencia ofrece una nueva herramienta de optimización mientras los anunciantes de automóviles buscan el equilibrio adecuado de gasto
La publicidad del automóvil, que durante mucho tiempo ha sido un pilar de los medios de comunicación nacionales y locales -sobre todo en el espacio televisivo, pero con un impacto digital cada vez mayor-, sigue desacelerando la inversión publicitaria. Esto sucede por varias razones, pero principalmente porque simplemente no hay tantos coches nuevos para vender, […]