In December 2017, The Atlantic said it was on the verge of putting up a metered paywall. Just a few months earlier, the legacy magazine publisher had launched a membership program, the Masthead, which had quickly gathered “thousands” of customers, and leadership expected that The Atlantic would be able to put up a proper paywall just a few months later.
There were a few kinks that needed to be ironed out – the price it would charge consumers, for one, the height of the paywall, for another – but the point was that 10 years after ditching its paywall, a new one would be erected, Bob Cohn, president of The Atlantic, said at the time.
More than a year later, that paywall still hasn’t launched, and there is no firm timetable in place for when it might. And instead of worrying about price point or the height of the paywall, the legacy publisher has gone back to the drawing board.
The Atlantic is currently conducting audience interviews to learn what kinds of products it could make to become a publication that people will feel compelled to subscribe to. That research is part of an extensive qualitative research program designed to help many parts of the organization turn The Atlantic into a habit-forming title, an increasingly common tactic among publishers interested in pursuing consumer revenue. The company needs to hire more engineers, data scientists and product managers, and while it expects that a new consumer revenue product will launch in the second half of 2019, there are no detailed plans for what final form the product will take.
Asked if preliminary testing caused a change to the announced plans, Cohn said it never rolled that first paywall out. “It was a realization that this requires a level of staffing that we’re not yet at.”
“We’re doing a lot more homework now,” Cohn added.
In the year that’s passed since The Atlantic’s announcement, publisher interest in consumer revenue has surged and paywalls have proliferated. That’s led some observers to worry subscriptions won’t work for most of the publishers pursuing them — and it’s raised the bar for those that still haven’t brought theirs to market.
Creating something that stands out in a crowded market requires a substantial lift, and the magazine publisher is right to be doing its homework, said Gwen Vargo, the director of reader revenue at the American Press Institute. “As we go from free to paid — and the pendulum is definitely swinging that way — you want to be sure that you’re producing content that’s valuable,” Vargo said. “There is a kind of upfront bet that you have to make, and you have to be prudent about it.”
Cohn insists there was no single moment that led to The Atlantic pausing its original paywall plans. “We made a decision to go back to first principles in the spring of 2018,” Cohn said. “The cause and effect we realized we only had one chance to get it right.”
That decision has informed much of the hiring that The Atlantic has done over the past 14 months. In February, the publisher announced plans to go on a 100-person hiring spree meant to grow headcount by more than 30 percent, to 430 people; at the time of the announcement, The Atlantic had 29 open existing positions as well.
To date, it has hired 78 people across the organization, doubling the size of its product team, which includes engineering, audience development, data science, design, growth and consumer revenue to around 50 people, Cohn said.
That group had been overdue for major investment, Cohn said, and it will need more resources to execute The Atlantic’s consumer revenue strategy at a high level. The Atlantic plans to hire an additional 50 people in 2019, a third of whom will serve on its product side, Cohn said.
Last year, The Atlantic grew its top-line revenues 13 percent, Cohn said, with every category of revenue except print advertising growing double-digits. Advertising, even with a decline in print, grew 10 percent. Its events business grew 30 percent.
Where consumer revenue fits into The Atlantic’s revenue pie isn’t clear. A spokesperson declined to offer information about how many members the Masthead currently has, saying only that it remains “relatively small” and that it is “beating industry retention rates” for first-year membership programs. The spokesperson also declined to comment on how big a slice it would like consumer revenue to eventually represent.
Note: This story has been updated from the original version that was sent to Digiday+ members. It adds clarification on The Atlantic’s work so far in developing a paywall and other details including how The Atlantic is using the audience research it is currently conducting.
Inside Hearst UK’s multi-pronged approach to third-party cookie replacements
Hearst UK's Ryan Buckley and Faye Turner are testing everything from 50,000-person panels to clean rooms.
Out of home fights for greater ad share as it cites better value on action taken by consumers
An OAAA study found that OOH is on par with other media in eliciting action from those consumers who recall seeing the ads. And since it's much less costly, it's a more effective means of influencing consumers.
The Rundown: BuzzFeed Inc. revenue up by 26% despite hits to commerce business, expects similar momentum in Q2
Despite significant declines in BuzzFeed Inc.’s commerce business, overall revenue was up, due to increases in the company's advertising and content arms.
SponsoredHow marketers and retailers are unlocking the true value of retail media
Ben Kneen, senior director of product management, Xandr It’s a challenging time for retailers in the advertising industry. As they cope with supply chain woes and inflation-related pressures, they seek high-margin revenue streams amid evolving privacy regulations and massive shifts in identity solutions — including IDFA, the deprecation of third-party cookies and more. In light […]
Member ExclusiveMedia Buying Briefing: Omnicom Media Group tackles supply-chain challenges for its clients
The media agency network created a metric designed to help brands calculate where and when to redirect media spend as a result of supply chain issues they face — rather than just putting a halt on spend when there’s a supply crunch.
The Rundown: Podcast production companies and platforms pitch diverse audiences and ad targeting improvements at IAB’s Podcast Upfront
The three-day podcast-focused event highlighted improvements in dynamic ad insertion, machine learning and diversity of creators, content and audiences.