Publishers are starting to see the results of Facebook Instant Articles, which launched widely last month, giving them a way to post fast-loading content directly to the social network. They have been treating the new format as an experiment to see what it means for their businesses to give their distribution over to Facebook so fully. They are tweaking the type of content they post as Instant Articles, how much they post and figuring out how they impact performance and monetization.
Games and entertainment media company IGN said Instant Articles reach almost double the number of people on the social network than other posts. PopSugar saw a surge in mobile traffic but a dip in time spent with its content. Meanwhile, Business Insider said Facebook is doing a fine job managing monetization, selling the ads for them. Other publishers sell their own ads, and say that works, too.
“The hope was that we would see an increase in reach and ad inventory, and we saw way more than we were expecting,” said Todd Northcutt, IGN’s vp of product.
IGN is generating 20 percent more ad revenue from Instant Articles, compared to what non-Instant Articles deliver, because of the increase in impressions coming from Facebook, Nortcutt said.
As the initial results trickle in, here is what else publishers said they have found, so far.
“There was a big question going in,” said Chris George, svp of product marketing at PopSugar. “Would the algorithm weigh Instant Articles more than non-Instant ones? Facebook said that’s not the case, but the consumer is understanding these types of posts are a better experience, and are more likely to click.”
So while Facebook claims not to give an artificial boost to publishers using Instant Articles, more people wind up seeing the posts because they get more clicks, which gives them a higher ranking to show up in more people’s feeds.
IGN shared a week’s worth of data that showed the reach of Instant Articles versus non-Instant Articles. Reach was nearly double: Instant posts reached on average 12 percent of the publisher’s total audience of more than 3.5 million Facebook fans, while non-Instant reached an average of 7 percent of fans.
This is where it gets tricky. PopSugar, for instance, puts a lot of stock in driving readers to its website, where it tries to keep them engaged for as long as possible. PopSugar said its mobile traffic is up 36 percent since it joined the program in April, because the site is able to include Instant traffic as if it were a website visit. ComScore does the third-party measuring for publishers to verify the traffic numbers for them and advertisers.
Even though traffic is up, PopSugar said time spent is lower in the Instant Articles by half compared to the average session of a reader visiting the website. “With Instant Articles, by their very nature, the format doesn’t see the same level of engagement,” George said.
PopSugar said it is experimenting with different types of media — more than simple articles — like polls, recipes and other formats to get Instant Article readers to spend as much time as they do on the website.
Publishers are still working out the formula of what type content works best as Instant Articles — links, photo galleries, polls, and other types of media — and how much of it to post.
“We are doing articles only, no photo galleries, slideshows, video. We’re focusing on the simplest, most basic story type,” said Julie Hansen, COO of Business Insider.
Business Insider is posting about 10 percent of its articles as Instant Articles, meanwhile other publishers like The Washington Post have been posting every article in that format.
Facebook has given publishers two options to monetize: The publisher can sell the ad units in the Instant Articles, and bundle the traffic with its own website, because of comScore’s ability to measure the visits on Facebook. Or publishers can allow Facebook to sell the inventory through its own ad network.
“We’re filling with our own ads, treating this new inventory as part of our cross-screen ‘All IGN’ inventory,” IGN’s Northcutt said. “Since that was our strategy going in, this is equivalent to organic growth on mobile for us. The ability to measure audience here via comScore was a brilliant move on Facebook’s part, since it allows us to capture this audience there, too.”
Business Insider is taking the other route, letting Facebook fill the ad slots, and it is seeing the same level of monetization from Instant Articles as it gets on its websites.
Business Insider’s own advertisers don’t appear to be clamoring for space in Instant Articles, anyway, Hansen said. “We haven’t seen any particular demand from our own advertisers; there isn’t any resistance either, but we’ve relied on Facebook to monetize, and they’ve done a nice job,” Hansen said.
Member ExclusiveMedia Buying Briefing: Omnicom Media Group tackles supply-chain challenges for its clients
The media agency network created a metric designed to help brands calculate where and when to redirect media spend as a result of supply chain issues they face — rather than just putting a halt on spend when there’s a supply crunch.
The Rundown: Podcast production companies and platforms pitch diverse audiences and ad targeting improvements at IAB’s Podcast Upfront
The three-day podcast-focused event highlighted improvements in dynamic ad insertion, machine learning and diversity of creators, content and audiences.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: Publishers continue to push advertisers to check out their shoppable video pitches
In this week's Media Briefing, media editor Kayleigh Barber checks in on how publishers' attempts to win over advertisers with their shoppable video and livestream shopping programs are going.
SponsoredHow marketers and retailers are unlocking the true value of retail media
Ben Kneen, senior director of product management, Xandr It’s a challenging time for retailers in the advertising industry. As they cope with supply chain woes and inflation-related pressures, they seek high-margin revenue streams amid evolving privacy regulations and massive shifts in identity solutions — including IDFA, the deprecation of third-party cookies and more. In light […]
In graphic detail: How influencers drive social commerce sales
Influencers have a huge impact on the success of social commerce, and yet a large portion of micro influencers are not given the credit they deserve.
The Trade Desk weathers Q1 headwinds with $315 million in revenues marking a 43% increase
More publishers join its OpenPath land grab but sources fear trading deals can come with strings attached