Publisher commerce ambitions will hit a wall in 2018
Publishers know by now that farming on a platform’s land can be dangerous.
Just as publishers have learned that they’d struggle to monetize their content on Facebook, those that spent to build businesses based on e-commerce affiliate commissions will get a wake-up call in 2018, as Amazon cements its place as an online shopping destination and cuts the affiliate commission rates it pays publishers.
Digital publishers have glommed on to e-commerce as a revenue stream as ad revenue has dried up. According to BI Intelligence, e-commerce represented the fastest-growing revenue segment for publishers in 2016, a trend continued in 2017 and surpassed in some corners only by video.
Over the past year, Wirecutter, The New York Times-owned commerce-focused site, has nearly doubled its editorial head count to 55. PopSugar overhauled its merchandising strategy, turning its site from a recommendations source into a standalone shopping destination. Even news-focused publishers CNN and NBC News have launched online shopping guides.
But just as Facebook was the catalyst for an industrywide pivot to video in 2017, Amazon powered most of that commerce growth. Some publishers derive as much as 80 percent of their e-commerce revenues from Amazon because Amazon drives the strongest conversion rates with most publishers’ readers. Amazon has the largest base of mobile app installations among shopping apps. Few retailers, aside from Walmart or Alibaba, have the scale necessary to compete with Amazon on price.
Over the next few years, Amazon’s grip on e-commerce will only tighten. Jeff Bezos’s behemoth is expected to account for half of all U.S. e-commerce by 2021, according to Needham & Co.
In 2018, publishers will have to reckon with what happens once Amazon dominates a particular product category. Publishers say that in categories such as fitness gear, Amazon has dropped the affiliate commission rates it pays publishers to near zero after it realized that consumers visit its platform first to buy product, depriving publishers of a revenue stream they’ve come to rely on.
“[Amazon] could fuck us all tomorrow if they wanted to,” said one executive, who asked not to be named because Amazon already represents a top-five source of revenue for that exec’s employer.
Some publishers have tried to reduce their dependence on Amazon. Some take the affiliate conversion data they get from Amazon and use it to create direct deals with product manufacturers to sell products directly at a higher margin.
In theory, the best way for commerce-focused publishers to reduce their dependence on Amazon is to create and sell products themselves and own the entire process from checkout onwards, a step that publishers including BuzzFeed, Clique and Chive Media have taken.
But being a retailer is hard. Warehouse space is expensive. Customer service, fulfillment and supply chain issues are expensive, complicated and totally divorced from the rhythms and skill sets that power digital publishing. Amazon has made free shipping, free returns, one-click orders and other perks table stakes of online shopping, and publishers can’t compete with that.
A rare exception is Clique, which has wanted to put commerce at the heart of its strategy since its inception in 2007 and raised $15 million to build a consumer brands department.
One of the companies that invested in that round? Amazon, which has lately taken an especial interest in trying to build its own brands. “They said, ‘We’re interested in learning from you,’” Clique co-founder Katherine Power said.
More typical is the experience of millennial women-focused Bustle, which started in e-commerce by making deals directly with brands and retailers in pursuit of higher commissions. But the conversion rates, bogged down by different check-out schemes and other problems, didn’t drive enough revenue, and Bustle switched to Amazon after less than a year.
Member ExclusiveDisruption, served one thread at a time: The weird world of DTC thoughtleader Twitter (1/23)
On direct-to-consumer startup Twitter, everything is a branding lesson.
WTF…are standard contractual clauses
With the Privacy Shield dead, companies are moving to standard contractual clauses so data transfer between the EU and U.S. is GDPR compliant.
‘You have to innovate on the value’: The disparate state of virtual event ticketing
A virtual event happens every minute as saturation nears and publishers keep giving it away for free.
SponsoredPublishers: Assessing risk and ensuring payments in times of crisis
As the industry navigates the continued impacts of COVID-19, here’s the questions publishers should ask their programmatic partners or ad management providers to protect themselves from clawbacks and lost revenue.
‘We have our work cut out for us’: How Havas is launching a major campaign to overcome its lack of racial diversity in the U.S.
Recent diversity data from Havas shows that just 6.1% of the 4,000 it employs in the U.S. are black.
‘Take back some market share from Amazon’: Publishers are testing their own versions of Prime Day
With Amazon Prime Day delayed, publishers with commerce operations are creating their own shopping holidays.