Lately, media companies, including The New York Times, ESPN and USA Today, have rolled out ad products that they say can match ads to people in certain moods.
USA Today Network in 2016 started categorizing its content by topic and tone, and scoring it based on the emotions it’s believed to most evoke. Last year, it started to sell advertising based on that knowledge with a product called Lens Targeting. Kelly Andresen, svp and head of Get Creative, USA Today Network’s content studio, said the publisher is trying to show a link between the emotions a story is likely to evoke and ad performance. An ad campaign for a nonprofit that was targeted to people reading inspirational stories resulted in a 25 percent higher donation rate than ads that weren’t targeted, she said.
“We’ve seen a gradual increase in RFPs, advertisers aren’t asking for audience by demographic but psychographic,” Andresen said. “This is one step to find those psychographics instead of numbers you can get from outside parties.”
The New York Times rolled out a tool earlier this year called Project Feels that lets advertisers target ads to content based on emotional responses the content is predicted to have. ESPN has been pitching a tool to target sports fans on its digital properties based on their changing emotional state during a game. Now it’s trying to apply all that know-how to the rest of Disney’s properties. The tool is called LiveConnect and takes the sports preferences that its logged-in users provide and overlays that with data about how people feel based on how their team is doing and line that up with advertisers’ goals. That could mean showing ads for travel or other celebratory experiences to people whose team is on a winning streak — or not advertising to them at all if their team is losing.
“We were trying to find any scalable way to deliver the right message at the right time,” said Vikram Somaya, svp, global data officer and ad platforms at ESPN. “Sports, there’s a lot of potential messages around it. The fact is, we’re in the emotion-generating business. We have a lot of first-party data we can use with a lot of transactions with the consumer; why wouldn’t we do it?”
“It’s something a lot of media planners have been trying to do for years,” Chris Wexler, svp and executive director of media and analytics at Cramer‑Krasselt. “It just depends on how rich the data set is. It’s an exciting frontier because we’re looking for people who are open to our message, and emotional state is a key part of it. Demographics based targeting is better than no targeting. Behavior-based is better than demographics. If you put it in order of importance, mood is above behavioral.”
Hitting people with a message when they’re likely to be receptive is as old as advertising, but using artificial intelligence to target people based on their mood is another level of manipulation. Publishers and agencies say they draw the line at using personally identifiable data or data without saying what it’s being collected for. “This is really about focusing on finding better-qualified audiences, but this is not at a point where we can manipulate mood through content,” Andresen said. ESPN’s Somaya said it won’t use information it thinks people don’t feel should be publicly revealed, keeping in mind its family-focused Disney audience, which means everything from health to political preferences to sexual orientation. That data isn’t as commercially valuable as information they willingly provide (like sports interests) anyway, he added.
The biggest challenge is proving mood-based targeting works and at scale. It’s still just an “occasional” part of the ad sell at publishers. It takes a client that’s willing and able to work closely with the publisher on figuring out what the ROI should be, measuring it, and spending the premium that’s often charged.
Agencies also want more information about the methodology. It’s an easier sell with music because it’s easier to believe as companies like Spotify might say that people who listen to break-up music are sad.
Josh Baines, who works on publisher strategy at Oracle, whose Grapeshot product powers mood-based targeting, said the topic is getting more visibility because it provides a deeper level of targeting and chance to qualify people’s mindsets. Showing it drives real business outcomes and not just fluffy metrics will be key to growing its adoption, though, he said.
Other categories outside of music are a harder sell. Some advertisers shy away from being around news because they think it will create a negative association with their brands with readers. For news publishers, one hope of A.I. is to change advertisers’ associations to news. Andresen said USA Today Network found that people are equally drawn to “positive” versus “negative” stories when they come to the site, a finding it uses in pitches to advertisers. “It’s helpful for us to explain that to advertisers: You don’t have to walk away from the whole news category.”
Wexler isn’t so sure. “In music, they can claim to know when you’re sad. We’d be particularly skeptical about news content — are we going to guess that because someone’s in Alabama they’re angry about something versus someone in New York?” he said.
Gannett reviews employee blowback to social media policy memo after Roe overturn
After receiving criticism for forbidding its journalists from posting opinions on the Supreme Court striking down Roe last week, Gannett is reviewing employee perspectives.
Bloomberg Green’s expansion increases its service-oriented coverage
Bloomberg's climate vertical is adding new products and coverage areas to lean into solutions-oriented journalism.
Companies turn to employee resource groups to manage internal discourse around the abortion ruling
Companies are using ERGs to facilitate employee conversations, as well as executive leadership via companywide emails to employees stressing their support for wellbeing and the availability of managers for support.
SponsoredWhy the caliber of content is paramount for advertisers
Agata Brodniewska, brand safety manager, Dailymotion Content is king when attracting consumers but is equally essential when courting advertisers. While both stakeholders want many of the same things, they most notably want relevant content they can count on to deliver an accurate and honest message without confusion or misinformation. This is especially important for advertisers […]
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: The pros and cons of three commerce pricing models
In this week’s Media Briefing, media editor Kayleigh Barber breaks down the different pricing models that commerce publishers use.
Vice Media Group brings back program for small, Black-owned businesses
VMG and the National Urban League are bringing back their program offering marketing and consulting services to Black-owned businesses -- to a smaller group.