Is Medium for Real or Is It Just a YAP?

Another day, another new distraction — or as my editor Brian Morrissey calls it, a YAP: Yet Another Platform. Yesterday the grand Internet publishing experiment continued with the launch of Medium, brought to you by Evan Williams and Biz Stone, the guys who gave us Twitter. Medium, as the name would imply, sets out to be the Goldilocks of publishing: not too short, not too long, just the right length of formatting. Great. Only one question: how will it make money?

Williams and Stone are attempting to “rethink publishing.” What that entails is still anyone’s guess. Medium’s idea is to celebrate content and not the author, so that topic trumps author, a blend of blog, social network, photo-sharing site.

Medium faces an uphill battle on three fronts: no advertising (so no revenue unless they charge for use, which leads to); who will use it (“beyond an initial crowd of try-anything-once types,” as Nieman Labs points out, because…); there are already other platforms to do this.

One of the truisms of media (old and new) is that technology and advertising are in the driver’s seat. We’ve seen how technology has upended the publishing landscape. It may sound reductionist, but advertising, no matter your personal feelings about it, is vital for a publisher. Show me a publisher who can survive without any form of advertising and I’ll show you a cat riding atop a unicorn through a rainbow.

More in Media

How Shira Lazar grew social account ‘What’s Trending’ to seven figures in revenue

Shira Lazar saw that creator-led media brands were the future 15 years ago, and now the entire industry has caught on.

Condé Nast, Hearst among 300 media execs to push federal ‘bad bots’ bill on AI scraping

More than 300 publishing execs are heading to Washington, D.C to push Congress to crack down on AI bots that scrape their content without permission.

Digiday Publishing Summit September 2026 Recap: How publishers are rebuilding for the post-search era

Execs at DPS described how they’re preparing for a post-search era by prioritizing direct audiences, diversified revenue and AI strategies.