Haters gonna hate: A guide to the backlash against Vice
The hype cycle for publishers is a cruel thing. One day the darling, the next you’re getting a Code:Red.
Just look at Vice. In 20 years, Vice has gone from being a small counterculture magazine to becoming the media world’s latest obsession, earning it a $2.5 billion valuation. And, inevitably, it has attracted its share of haters on the way to the top. Lately, the criticisms have gotten louder, some due to professional rivalry, others out of jealousy and still others with a real point to make.
Here’s a look at the case against Vice Media, from the eyes of its detractors.
Does Vice really know millennials better than anyone else?
The conventional wisdom about Vice is that it natively speaks the language of hard-to-reach millennials in a way that few existing media brands can match. It turns out that that’s not exactly true. ComScore data from July, for example, found that The New York Times reached 15.9 millennial readers — 20 percent more than Vice did. Likewise, Vice’s millennial reach was also outpaced by fellow millennial publications like BuzzFeed, Complex and Elite Daily.
Vice has a big valuation, but limited reach
Questions about Vice’s millennial reach also touch on the site’s limited reach overall. While Vice claims that it has 150 million unique visitors a month, its comScore numbers give it a much smaller reach of just 9.3 million people. The story is the same on YouTube, where Vice and Vice News have 5 million and 977,908 subscribers, respectively.
The problem? That’s YouTube’s audience, not Vice’s.
“They don’t even own their own voice because all of their scale is on other people’s platforms,” said one media executive. “How can they be worth that much and only have less than 10 million monthly UVs?”
Vice is one big shill for brands
While Vice is a media company, its real business is in Virtue, its agency arm. Last year, the site launched The Creator’s Project, a site created in partnership with Intel. More recently, Vice partnered with brands like McDonald’s and Johnson & Johnson for do-gooder site Collectively, which focuses on sustainable innovation around the world.
Often, this coziness with brands can cause some friction with the rest of Vice’s business. Charles Davis, a former associate editor at Vice, told Capital New York last week that Vice has killed stories that could compromise the company’s relationship with advertisers. The claim echoed previous ones by Vice employees, who claimed that Vice regularly makes editorial compromises in an effort to make its brand partners happy.
And this is what Vice will email a freelancer who is potentially jeopardizing business: pic.twitter.com/k03HSNTbSL
— Charles Davis (@charliearchy) October 1, 2014
Vice is just another media sweatshop.
For a company worth $2.5 billion, you’d think that Vice would be able to pay its reporters a decent wage. Not so. Vice employees and contractors told Gawker in May that Vice paid them just $30,000 a year, which they say is barely enough to cover New York City rents. The story touched off a firestorm on Twitter, with Vice CEO Shane Smith vaguely defending his company’s pay practices. “Employment is a market. We pay market if we didn’t no one would work for us. It’s simple,” he wrote.
Vice News isn’t real news.
Vice has also taken heat for its unconventional approach to news coverage, which typically involves reporters actively being a part of the stories they’re reporting. Case in point: In a particularly illustrative stunt, Vice last year sent reporters, along with former basketball player Dennis Rodman, to North Korea, where they were whisked from location to location on a heavily controlled tour around the country. Vice then turned the trip into an episode of its Vice News HBO show.
But while Vice has covered some big stories, the company’s brand of news coverage hasn’t sat well with traditional media types. Nowhere was this backlash more apparent than in a 2010 interview between New York Times media columnist David Carr and Shane Smith, who suggested that the Times wasn’t covering serious news well enough. Carr’s response: “Just because you put on a fucking safari helmet and looked at some poop doesn’t give you the right to insult what we do,” he said.
Carr, however, has come back around as of late, realizing that Vice was quickly becoming something that couldn’t be ignored. “Being the crusty old-media scold felt good at the time, but recent events suggest that Vice is deadly serious about doing real news that people, yes, even young people, will actually watch,” he wrote.
‘Total whack a mole’: Rogue political ads create mounting brand safety problems for publishers
The political ads flowing through open exchanges are creating a brand safety dilemma, despite the safeguards put in place.
‘An election night that could last weeks’: How news publishers are updating their digital strategies for the results long haul
Before they are able to make their call on who wins the presidency, news publishers could have a month-and-a-half past Nov.3 to compete for audiences.
‘Asymmetrical in every sense’: The latest console wars see Sony and Microsoft pursue diverging battle plans
The console wars are back, setting the stage for the latest bout in the long-running battle between Sony’s Playstation and Microsoft’s Xbox brands.
SponsoredB2B events were broken before the pandemic, their online reinvention is creating positive change
Kim Darling, executive producer, Inbound Farewell lanyards, business cards and branded pens — it’ll be some time before people get their hands on these souvenirs of in-person events again. As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to transform the way people work, buy, sell, socialize and entertain themselves, the global events industry is facing its biggest-ever challenge. […]
‘Walk before you run’: Sports publishers look to blow out their betting content
Over the past 12 months, several large sports media brands have signed partnership deals with sports books
‘It’s a virtuous cycle’: Audiences and advertisers seek health and wellness content and publishers are seeing green
Publishers are building new content products that give audiences more health and wellness content and advertisers more partner opportunities.