Join us Dec. 1-3 in New Orleans for the Digiday Programmatic Marketing Summit
Facebook is dealing with doubts about whether it will live up to expectations. This is a normal part of the hype cycle most hot tech companies go through. But under it all, there appears a fundamental misunderstanding on the part of Silicon Valley and Wall Street. Facebook is not Google.
Google’s remarkable rise was, as Peter Hershberg points out, very under-appreciated. Google’s IPO opened many people’s eyes to the wonder of search advertising, a “beautiful system” in the words of ex-Yahoo CEO Terry Semel where ads were actually helpful, unobtrusive and incredibly effective. Dalton Caldwell rightly termed what Google accomplished as “alchemy”: It took search results pages that were nearly worthless to Yahoo and made them incredibly valuable. Google’s alchemy, aka AdWords, was done by adopting the Web’s original native ad format, sponsored listings, and marrying that to the most powerful piece of data the Web’s produced: the intent signal.
That is a once-in-a-generation business model. AdWords gushed money and funded God knows how many harebrained efforts from Knol to Lively to space exploration. But AdWords ended up teaching Silicon Valley the wrong lesson. It taught entrepreneurs and VCs that the ad business was a basic engineering problem that could be solved with an algorithm. In fact, the biggest section of advertising (brand building) doesn’t work that way at all. There is more art than science in brand advertising.
Facebook, to its credit, is trying to pioneer a new form of advertising based on social signals. These are not direct intent signals like Google had in search. It will always be harder to turn a social signal into ad dollars because Facebook is in the attention-bartering business, a messy market that requires relationships, hand-holding and all sorts of stuff Silicon Valley pretends doesn’t matter. On top of that, Facebook is betting on a native advertising format, sponsored stories, that is unproven and foreign to marketers. It will take time for Facebook to sort this out, if it does.
Until then, time to stop comparing Facebook to Google.
More in Media
Ringier’s editorial advisor says the next editors-in-chief might come from audience development
As Ringier rethinks what its future newsrooms should look like, a provocative idea is on the table
WTF are GEO and AEO? (and how they differ from SEO)
Future success no longer looks like being top of the blue links on Google’s index or any other search engine’s – it will center on how to ensure your content gets surfaced in AI answer engines too.
Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince on why Google must ‘play by the same rules’ as other AI companies
Digiday spoke with Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince a few days after he met with the U.K. regulator on why he believes Google will inevitably have to split its AI and search crawler.