Email newsletters have a measurement problem
Publishers are having a love affair with newsletters. Their ability to give a direct line to readers provides a handy bulwark against Facebook. Traditional publishers are pouring resources into them, like The New York Times, with its 12-person newsletter staff and others that have appointed newsletter “editors.”
It’s typical for publishers to say the primary function for their newsletters is audience development, and with reason: Newsletters have a measurement problem. There’s no comScore for newsletters. Advertisers have to take publishers at their word when it comes to numbers like subscriber size and open rate.
Pete Sena, chief creative officer of digital marketing agency Digital Surgeons, said he automatically discounts the subscriber numbers publishers report, knowing they can be inflated by multiple email sign-ups by the same person or ISPs blocking delivery.
“It is a problem,” he said. “I don’t trust that number, because we all know lists come and go. I don’t believe [publishers] overtly lie, but I do believe there’s a little bit of omission of how valid are those emails.”
Not only that, but publishers don’t share information like what device the subscriber is using and what time of day it is when they open the email. “You get very limited metrics,” he said.
Adding to the problem, MailChimp, the company that serves many email newsletters, has technological limits in how it measures open rates, which can lead to underestimates of how much email newsletters are read.
Then there’s the issue of publishers fluffing their subscription numbers by using come-ons like contests, which may yield email addresses if not necessarily loyal readers.
Yet these issues are missing from the frothy coverage of newsletters like TheSkimm, with its “massive subscriber list” (it claims 4 million) and the “exceptional” Lenny Letter (it claims 400,000 subscribers).
Newsletters face something of a chicken-and-egg problem. Right now, buyers are OK with the lack of independent, third-party measurement because they’re not buying newsletters on their own, so there’s little incentive for the publisher to provide it. Newsletters are usually part of a larger ad buy (and sometimes thrown in for free), or a sponsorship, and as such, they’re low risk to the advertiser.
In the case of Quartz, for example, it largely relies on reach and performance data from MailChimp when it comes to measuring its popular email newsletter, the Daily Brief (which it says goes to more than 200,000 subscribers), and clients are fine with that, the publisher said.
Carlos Watson, co-founder and CEO of Ozy, another publisher with a big focus on newsletters, pointed out that measurement of web pages is inflated, and that newsletters offer a way to connect with consumers in a more personal way. Advertisers and publishers do need to be creative to avoid alienating consumers in such a personal medium, though, he pointed out.
As long as there’s no outside audit, newsletters’ financial growth will be limited, though.
“We see them as part of something bigger, and it’s the something bigger we value,” said Doug Rozen, chief digital and innovation officer at OMD. “No advertiser is using newsletters as their own marketing vehicle. It’s not a campaign in and of itself. It’s an added premium.”
The Skimm also benefits from the cool factor; it’s just the kind of “micro content” a lot of advertisers are looking for now, and a lot of young media buyers are readers themselves, said Lisa Cucinotta, director of social strategy and business development for Horizon Media.
Sena, while skeptical of publisher-provided subscriber numbers, says newsletters are worth doing anyway because they’re still a better way to reach a specific audience than a broad-reach campaign, even if the advertiser is reaching fewer people than the publisher would have him believe.
Dave Helmreich, COO of LiveIntent, a leader in newsletter ad sales, with more than 1,300 publisher clients, as expected, said the medium has a lot going for it. The fact that subscribers have to take multiple steps to opt in makes them valuable to advertisers, and the medium is immune to issues like viewability, clutter and ad blocking that dog online display advertising. “There is no ad blocker for email,” he said. He wouldn’t share dollar figures but said LiveIntent’s revenue has been increasing 50 percent or more a year for the past few years, and he expects that to continue.
But he admits there is room for improvement in measurement as buyers demand more data to understand how to value its performance. Demand to measure ad viewability is coming, and the traditional way of doing that on the web doesn’t work in email, for example.
“Every buyer wants to understand how to pay for it, measure it, how it looks compared to things they’ve been doing for years,” Helmreich said.
Cheat Sheet: At IAB Podcast Upfront, diverse voices take center stage while podcast advertising revenue and audiences boom
Most of the companies that presented at the IAB Podcast Upfront signaled they had or were going to add more diversity to their programming, both in hosts and content.
Member ExclusiveMedia Briefing: What media companies’ latest earnings reports say about the state of the industry
Media companies' Q1 earnings reports signaled a continued return to business as usual — for better or worse, depending on the company's digital business.
‘Brands tend to be selective’: OMG report offers options to media buyers facing upfront inventory crunch
With a tight upfront TV marketplace expected, one agency group is recommending alternatives in video and CTV.
SponsoredHow The Company Store is reimagining customer experiences for pandemic-era growth
Throughout the pandemic, some retail categories have been inherently successful. Home furnishings and décor are among them; with consumers spending so much more time at home, updates and renovations flourished. Criteo data from the first half of 2020 showed sales for items like outdoor furniture sets up 434% year over year, with other home items […]
‘You’re fixing a number, not changing the culture’: Confessions of a media exec on diversity quotas
In the rush to improve diversity rates, businesses are in danger of overlooking more fundamental ways to sustain inclusivity in the workplace, according to our latest Confessions interviewee.
‘Direct revenue driver’: How local broadcaster News 12 is partnering with Google to build a younger audience
Local broadcaster used support and funding from Google News Initiative to build a new tool that can automatically identify and feed video content into new website verticals.