AT&T’s anti-texting campaign: lots of impressions, zero sucess
AT&T’s “It Can Wait” campaign has generated hundreds of millions of social impressions and actions over the past two years, but no tangible results. The lack of results illustrates how difficult it is for brands that are successful on social media to affect change in the real world.
Frustrated by the lack of success, AT&T has turned to Twitter to run a survey among certain users regarding their awareness of “It Can Wait” — and whether they associate the campaign with AT&T and the #x hashtag with texting while driving.
Twitter surveys like this are available to brands that commit to spending a certain amount with Twitter in an upfront deal, although Twitter wouldn’t disclose the minimum spend required for a survey.
In this case, the survey and internal AT&T research illustrate just how fruitless AT&T’s “It Can Wait” campaign has been.
AT&T’s failure to curb texting and driving is not for lack of trying. The company launched “It Can Wait” in March 2010 with the aim of stigmatizing the activity as Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) did with drinking and driving. Over the last two years, AT&T has done everything from outreach sessions at schools and homepage takeovers to tweets from Ryan Seacrest and a Werner Herzog-helmed documentary about the dangers of texting while driving called “From One Second to the Next.”
— Ryan Seacrest (@RyanSeacrest) September 19, 2013
Internal AT&T documents on the campaign reveal that “It Can Wait” has rendered hundreds of millions of impressions but few results. And given that the campaign has been so focused on digital — and social, specifically — it raises doubts about whether social engagements correspond to a brand’s goal.
They don’t, according to Jeff Melton, chief analytics and media officer at digital agency MRY. AT&T selected MRY in April to take over the “It Can Wait” campaign from incumbent BBDO.
“For example, consumers might share, like or comment on a post because of the imagery but not fully agree with the copy or messaging,” Melton added. “That’s why the industry is moving away from measuring engagements to partnering with third parties for more accurate measurement.”
Still, AT&T listed those hundreds of millions of Facebook, Twitter and YouTube users it reached with “It Can Wait” in the successes portion of an internal document dated Feb. 11, 2014 (slide 15 in the document embedded below).
But buried a little further down in the document is the percentage of consumers who reported not having seen any messages regarding the dangers of texting while driving: up two points from 38 percent in September 2012 to 40 percent in June 2013 (slide 40).
More troubling, the percentage of people who copped to texting while driving increased as well, albeit ever so slightly, over this period of time, from 68 percent to 69 percent (slide 41).
The ineffectiveness of “It Can Wait” was further underscored by another AT&T document dated March 2014 that showed that young people continue to text and drive despite acknowledging its danger. They justify the behavior — “[I] only do it at stop lights,” “[I] only check my phone” — and thus don’t feel compelled to stop (page 4 in the document embedded below).
For its part, AT&T defended its track record in a statement to Digiday. “As part of our It Can Wait campaign, we do surveys regularly measuring awareness and behavior change and have found we are making a difference — about a third of people say our no-texting-while-driving message has changed their behavior,” a spokesperson wrote.
But still, the perceived lack of a texting and driving problem among young people renders AT&T’s DriveMode app, which silences incoming calls and messages, worthless to many.
Granted, convincing the youngs to put down their phones is a far different ask than trying to upsell them on a data plan. But the results show that social media engagements are not themselves an indicator of success, and shouldn’t be measured as such.
Image via Shutterstock
‘The next billion-dollar sports franchise could be in esports’: Former Turner president David Levy on why his latest venture is in the burgeoning category
Digiday caught up with former Turner president David Levy to hear more about what the future of esports means for advertisers.
‘Quite cynical’: Publishers leery about Google’s $1 billion news licensing pot
Google said how the $1 billion will be divided is on a publisher-by-publisher basis related to each publishers' commitments.
‘Direct, inclusive and diverse’: Future’s latest female-focused title eyes U.S. audiences
Over the next few months, the publisher is focusing on building up an editorial team and audience in the U.S.
SponsoredHow to approach a long-term identity strategy, minus third-party cookies
Tom Lavan, strategy and corporate development, Xandr As all of the major browsers communicate plans and timelines for deprecating third-party cookies, anxiety continues to grow among advertisers that are looking for new ways to engage valuable customers on a one-to-one basis. The impending browser changes will promote consumer privacy and are aligned with recent laws […]
A year into new ownership, Sports Illustrated’s earnings have doubled through licensing deals
Sports Illustrated has penned 15 licensing deals with another three to five on the horizon for this year.
‘A good job of retaining’: Publishers see subscription resilience as evidence of sticky coronavirus-cohorts grows
As concerns about the future of advertising linger, digital publishers’ subscription revenues increased by 19.3% in the first three months of 2020.