Advertisers ‘don’t want to sound tone deaf’: Candid thoughts of publishers navigating crisis
Publishers are grappling with how to say solvent while facing declining advertising revenue, lost event sponsorships and ticket sales and dwindling commerce revenue.
While the Digiday Publishing Summit couldn’t take place in person in Vail, Colorado this year, would-be attendees still gathered virtually to discuss the challenges they’re facing within their businesses and what their strategies are for weathering the storm. Like most of our in-person town halls, this conversation was conducted under the Chatham House Rule, which allows reporters to share what people say without identifying them by name or company.
Panic pauses from clients decreases everyone’s advertising revenue.
Many advertisers are pausing ad campaigns due to financial strain and that is hard to debate. But for clients that are hesitating on their spend due to concerns around messaging against the coronavirus content, publishers can take a consultative approach to teach them how to make the messaging service related, in order to be a brand that is remembered as being front and center in having helped people during the pandemic.
“Not letting an advertiser out of whatever they want to do is a very short-term decision for your business. If you run this client’s campaign and it’s tone deaf and you force them to deliver you $100,000 or $500,000, when those lights come back on, they’re not coming back to you and that damage can be irreparable.”
Publishers are planning for a 25% to 30% hit to their advertising business.
One publisher said that advertisements running on coronavirus-related content are seeing a slight decrease in click-through rates. Though they attributed this dip to the type of inventory and campaigns running on those pages (more an increase of ads sold on the open auction versus higher impact ads) than to actual performance of the ads themselves.
Separately, an executive at a large digital publisher said it is seeing 30% lower CPMs on coronavirus pages versus non-coronavirus pages.
“Either supply chains are broken or they’re afraid of coronavirus adjacency — not because of brand safety but because they don’t want to sound tone deaf.”
Non-news publishers are seeing a drop-off in traffic.
For some publishers with non-news related content that audiences consume habitually, traffic may be down due to the break in the daily routine. One such publisher experiencing this found that traffic was down 25% last month. In these cases, subscriptions and direct sold campaigns were the most stable part of their business while programmatic is down upwards of 20% and other consumer products have not sold as much due to the decrease in traffic.
“If you’re not adapting your content strategy, you’re probably missing something. But from a product standpoint, I don’t think it’s time to change your products necessarily.”
The upside of virtual events is amplifying the audience.
When selling virtual events, obviously the networking and human interaction piece won’t be there, but the upside is amplifying the audience. While a live event might bring in a few hundred participants, a virtual event can be shared with more than 10 times that number. That value proposition is compelling and could potentially be a better product for partners.
Virtual events might not bring in as much revenue, but you can make up for that with saving time and money in planning it, such as turning out a new digital event in as little as 48 hours, according to one publisher.
“Our view is that we will see a dip in events revenue for this year just because it’s the nature of the beast. But through virtual events, there is a way to keep the business afloat.”
Events are multifaceted and not all events will be able to be replicated, especially large events like trade shows.
Making up all elements of the trade show is nearly impossible in a virtual format, especially for a two-or three-day conference because people won’t spend all that time in front of their computer. The other side of it is for trade shows that bring in tens of thousands of people and the loss of ticket revenue, which can be a few thousand dollars per pass, is significant. Therefore, rescheduling events to the fall is the best chance at recouping some of that money as a publisher, however that timeline is still hopeful at this point, several publishers agree.
“Sponsorships will be there but the pipeline for B2B media and those sellers are six to eight months. It’s not a consumer sell, so they’re going to need to get out a head of it here.”
GroupM’s Kieley Taylor and Amanda Grant are on the lookout for the future of identity in advertising
Between's the cookie's demise and Apple's anti-tracking moves, digital advertising's identity picture is still coming into focus.
Digiday’s updated breakdown of 12 publishers’ diversity statistics
A roundup of publishers' diversity reports reveals that nearly all of the companies included have majority white staff, leadership and new hires.
Member ExclusiveGlobal Publishing Summit Recap: prepare for a world without cookies
If you were listening in to our Global Publishing Summit on February 24-26, you’re probably still processing the wealth of insights, tips and strategies shared by all the speakers we heard from over the course of the summit. If you weren’t able to attend, fear not: we’re here to distill the key talking points from […]
SponsoredHow publishers are maximizing retention after the COVID-19 subscription surge
Michael D. Silberman, senior vice president of strategy, Piano For many publishers, 2020 was a good year for subscriptions, and the trend has continued into 2021. For example, over the last month, The New York Times grew active news subscriptions by 48%, and Insider has doubled its subscriber base to just over 100,000 in the […]
Member ExclusiveMedia Buying Briefing: Black-owned media companies step to the forefront of the upfront
Mediabrands is bringing together a raft of its biggest clients — about 20 Black-owned and Black-targeted media players — for an Equity upfront.
‘They’re solving a problem’: The Washington Post readies its Zeus platform for the buy side
Zeus currently offers more than 4 billion impressions per month across its participants' owned-and-operated sites.