Secure your place at the Digiday Publishing Summit in Vail, March 23-25
Jonathan Mendez is CEO of Yieldbot, an intent-based ad platform. Follow him on Twitter at @jonathanmendez.
Since the first ad exchange, the idea has propagated in the industry that as the buying and selling of digital advertising becomes automated — as machines replace the people — the industry will enter a glorious period of growth and liquidity.
The reality is much different. Agencies have now lost their ad server margins and ad tech companies built to exploit this media shift have razor-thin to non-existent margins. Personal relationships still rule deal-making. Just take a look at the size of some representative businesses through this programmatic “value” chain.
- Cadreon (agency trading desk): over 300 employees
- MediaMath (demand-side platform): 140 employees with 53 open positions
- AppNexus (buying platform): 1,000 employees within two years
- PubMatic (supply-side platform): 325 employees
It seems these automated media buying and selling companies need a shitload of people to make them run. Ideally, none of these people are salespeople, though we know that is not the case. I would argue on a dollar-for-dollar basis there were fewer people needed to support the industry back in the ad network heyday.
So if the new pipes VCs have spent $6 billion building require even more people to operate them than the old ones, where does that leave the automated future of online advertising? It leaves it with the one thing that can truly be automated, eliminate headcount and improve margin: performance optimization.
Algorithms are going to do a much better job optimizing than a person could ever do and will do it at scale. Performance optimization can be automated because it truly has all the ingredients necessary to benefit from algorithms that can take empirical data to quantify complex relationships, identify patterns, capture probability distribution, make intelligent decisions and learn from them.
Ad tech companies stacked with 25-year-old account managers and reporting analysts are not going to stand a chance in the next wave of intelligent optimization agents backed by terabytes of daily data fueling complex self-learning algorithms. Nor should they for our industry to reach its full potential and deserve the name ad “tech.” In the coming wave of auto-optimization and artificial intelligence, companies in our industry will not boast about how many employees they have but how few.
More in Media
Media Briefing: As AI search grows, a cottage industry of GEO vendors is booming
A wave of new GEO vendors promises improving visibility in AI-generated search, though some question how effective the services really are.
‘Not a big part of the work’: Meta’s LLM bet has yet to touch its core ads business
Meta knows LLMs could transform its ads business. Getting there is another matter.
How creator talent agencies are evolving into multi-platform operators
The legacy agency model is being re-built from the ground up to better serve the maturing creator economy – here’s what that looks like.