Wall Street shrugs at agency-transparency report
Stocks for Omnicom, IPG and WPP all closed slightly higher at market close Tuesday, underlining how difficult it is to really quantify the impact of the Association of National Advertisers report that found that non-transparent practices existed in many corners of the media agency landscape.
IPG closed about 1 percent higher at $23.96; Omnicom also about 1 percent at $83.27, and WPP closed at $116.27, 1.7 percent higher. No investment banks changed their ratings on big holding company stocks.
This might have been surprising to those watching to see how the market would respond to the findings of the report, which said, among other things, that rebates were pervasive and senior executives at agencies were aware of certain business practices that remained undisclosed to clients, including funneling business to owned (and higher margin) trading desks for programmatic ad buying.
“The report is not inconsistent with what we expected,” said Brian Wieser, analyst at Pivotal. “Only if you were an investor that slept through last year would you say, ‘oh my God’.”
The report was a result of an eight-month-long investigation after former Mediacom CEO Jon Mandel took the stage at an ANA event and said rebates were widespread in the U.S. market. In a research note at the time, Pivotal tried to figure out the material impact of that speed: It downgraded holding company stocks, but noted that it was too hard to figure out exactly the impact. Coverage does not disclose gross revenue versus revenues coming from media trading. And so investors can’t figure out how much agency growth has been supported by these non-transparent activities.
Another thing adding to the confusion is that a lot of this took place in the digital media space, which also isn’t broken out. And rebates are a problem in the U.S., and it’s hard also to ascertain the impact here versus globally.
One thing that might see more of an effect, said Wieser, is if investors start to appreciate the impact this will have on clients. If clients decide to use this report to cut fees or scrutinize contracts — the ANA certainly recommends the latter — it would have somewhat more of a material impact. “Then they can see it laid out clearly,” he said.
‘A gold rush moment’: Apple’s Vision Pro revives marketers’ AR ambitions
It adds a whole new meaning to the term “second screen."
The ANA parts ways with PwC in its ongoing ad tech transparency project
Sources claim the trade organization ended the relationship amid frustration with developments.
Culture Brands’ Eunique Jones Gibson wants to help brands uplift, empower stories for African Americans
When Eunique Jones Gibson, founder of the Black-owned marketing agency Culture Brands, launched her agency in 2017, the 39-year-old business leader wanted to demonstrate that she could ignite conversation, introspection and social change in the industry.
SponsoredWhat the measurement and currency discussion really means to TV advertisers
Ali Mack, head of TV and agency, Experian Major streaming video providers have recently made headlines by adopting new currencies for ad measurement, threatening Nielsen’s long-standing TV ratings monopoly. NBCUniversal, for example, has certified iSpot and VideoAmp as currencies for advanced audiences and formed the Joint Industry Committee with Paramount, TelevisaUnivision and Warner Bros. Discovery. […]
Danone’s Light + Fit brand invests in digital video ad spend, but won’t let go of linear TV
Danone-owned yogurt brand Light + Fit is doubling down on its streaming ad strategy, including investing in Netflix for the first time.
Marketing Briefing: Why marketers are seeking deeper partnerships with artists to remix songs, offer experiences
By working with musicians and celebrities, brands can potentially generate more attention and become a part of culture, according to agency execs, who say that brands are looking for anything that can help them connect to culture more deeply.