‘No one is rushing to commit Q4 budgets’: With its future in the U.S. increasingly uncertain, media buyers are holding back spending on TikTok
Now that TikTok has until September 20th to sell its U.S. operations or face the consequences of President Trump’s executive order signed late last Thursday, media buyers are stalling client marketing investment on the platform.
Prior to the executive order, “many advertisers were staying cautiously optimistic,” about TikTok’s ability to continue to operate in the U.S., according to Meghan Rao, account director at NXD Social. “But with everything so up in the air until the end of September, our plan is to hold off and recommend other platforms to use until we figure out what the next steps are for TikTok.”
While media buyers say that they are still optimistic that a sale will likely happen in time to keep the service operational in the U.S. and an option an option for dollars, they say that advertisers will likely test out TikTok competitors like Triller and now Instagram’s Reels. “No one is rushing to commit Q4 budgets” to TikTok, said one media buyer.
“Brands constantly want new content being created, so they’re doubling down on existing channels that are more stable,” said Franky Bernstein, CEO of shopping app Kickback. “We spend a lot of time with content creators and we’re focusing our efforts on Instagram because there’s more certainty that the investment in those followers will be worthwhile come September.”
For advertisers currently running campaigns on TikTok, buyers say it’s likely that they will continue with those campaigns rather than pull dollars away from the platform as there’s enough time between now and mid-September to keep those running. And last month’s Facebook dust up has likely made marketers more comfortable with moving social platform budgets on a dime.
“The boycott became a primer for marketers to be prepared for any moment where big moves come and they have to immediately act upon big sweeping action,” said Sargi Mann, evp and head of digital strategy and investments at Havas Media. “Marketers are more primed to look at and evaluate other [platform options quickly now].”
That said, advertisers are not spending anywhere near what they spend on Facebook on TikTok so moving ad dollars away from the platform is much simpler. TikTok is also not yet critical for driving business outcomes for advertisers in the way that Facebook is so moving ad dollars off the platform is not nearly as difficult.
And while advertisers are not leaving the platform en masse, the executive order has renewed brand safety concerns for advertisers. Those concerns now go beyond adjacency issues common with newer platforms, as advertisers have little control over the kinds of content their ads appear next to on TikTok. Advertisers are now also worried about the reputational risk associated with the platform as consumers worry about data privacy, according to media buyers.
Should TikTok’s U.S. operations be sold to Microsoft or Twitter or another potential buyer, that could help with the platform’s brand safety issues.
“We’re in a waiting game right now to figure out what happens,” said Jed Meyer, managing director for North America at independent media and marketing consultancy Ebiquity. “From a brand’s point of view they would like TikTok to be in the hands of a blue chip company like Microsoft or someone else. That gives advertisers more confidence that the data privacy issues will be addressed and they will invest in the platform.”
Horizon Media agencies ply new ground with incentive-based deals tied to compensation
Horizon Media agencies Big and Blue Hour cut an unusual incentive-based deal with DTC company Windmill, which lets client and agency make money if goals are reached.
How job seekers are standing out and staying top of mind during virtual job interviews
Candidates are competing for jobs on a computer screens so they are doing whatever they can to make their personalities and skills stand out.
As in-game ads expand, ad tech firms look to level up their services
As developers look to integrate advertisements more seamlessly into their titles, ad tech companies are rising to meet the challenge.
SponsoredHow the ad industry can use its borrowed time to future-proof first-party data solutions
Trent Lloyd, co-founder and head of brand solutions, Eyeota Google’s updated timeline for its Privacy Sandbox rollout, including its two-year delay of third-party cookie deprecation on Chrome, didn’t come as a surprise to many industry observers, given the limited utility of Google’s FLoC and the slow momentum of the Privacy Sandbox in the World Wide […]
‘We found a more engaged audience’: Why Kajabi is increasing its media spending on TV now
Kajabi, a SaaS company founded in 2011, isn’t alone in reconsidering advertising on TV as DTC brands have added more TV to the mix.
‘Marketers have to shift their expectations’: Despite turmoil in parts, Facebook’s ads business holds up against Apple’s privacy crackdown
Facebook’s resilience shouldn’t take anything away from the turmoil many of its advertisers are currently experiencing.