As the chief data and technology officer at IPG, Arun Kumar has plenty on his plate at the moment. Apple is limiting tracking on iPhones and iPads. In less than a year, Google’s Chrome browser is supposed to cut off third-party cookies. And both Apple and Google are threatening the advertising industry’s adoption of the IP address as a cross-platform identifier.
“’Stress’ is the middle name of my title right now,” Kumar said in the latest episode of the Digiday Podcast.
What is stressing out the agency executive, in particular, is the question of how companies can connect with current and potential customers and keep a pulse on people’s interests when their traditional means of doing so are being taken off the table. In addition to the technology providers’ tracking crackdowns, government regulators and privacy advocates increasingly see the tracking that underpins much of digital advertising as a form of involuntary surveillance. And Kumar acknowledged that the advertising industry has not done enough to convince people of the trade-offs of tracking.
“Is the industry doing a good enough job of explaining it? No, it’s not,” Kumar said.
Here are a few highlights from the conversation, which have been lightly edited for length and clarity.
The industry’s failing
The biggest fail has been that we in the marketing industry, the advertising industry, have not taken self-regulation as seriously as we should have. And therefore, there are a number of bodies that are doing a lot of work, but I don’t think any one single body has the influence. And frankly, I think that train has passed. I don’t think that self-regulation is the right answer.
The truths about tracking
I don’t think that anyone has communicated the truth about marketing to people. And when I say that, it is true that the advertising and marketing community haven’t done themselves any favors by explaining very clearly what the benefits are. Having said that, I don’t think that the privacy activists have truly talked to people about the impact of some of their decisions and how it’s changing people’s lives.
The cost of privacy
There are reports that have come out [stating that] companies have spent something like $475 million on compliance for [California’s privacy law] CCPA. Who’s paying the cost for privacy? Do we actually believe that these companies are going to keep the cost themselves and not pass the cost down to consumers? When you don’t share the data or when you have these policies, it’s not just going to impact whether you’re going to see an ad and whether a newspaper article is free or not. It’s actually impacting the cost of goods because compliance now has become that much more onerous.
Wave of AI-based marketing startups arrives as Microsoft, Google rush AI-based products to market
As Microsoft and Google compete with generative content, much smaller firms are building their own tech to tackle new territory
Digiday+ Research: On the eve of the Super Bowl, brands much prefer advertising on CTV over traditional TV
Brands prefer investing in connected TV over traditional TV — if they're spending on TV at all, a Digiday+ Research survey found.
Pinterest jockeys for position in platforms arms race for short-form video
The company’s recent deal with Conde Nast was just the start.
SponsoredAdvertising predictions that will shake up the media industry in 2023
Chris Kelly, CEO, Upwave Like many people, marketers and advertisers were ready to see 2022 come to a close. A year that started off promising was assailed by inflation, layoffs and the disastrous effects of RSV, the flu and additional COVID strains. Still, despite an uncertain outlook for 2023, there are plenty of reasons for […]
Will Twitter continue to be where brands comment on the Super Bowl – or will TikTok play usurper?
As TikTok continues to dominate marketing conversations, experts sound off on whether or not it will become the future second screen for live events.
Brands stay silent on Tyre Nichols killing as marketers signal it as an industry backslide
Compared to the things that were said and acted upon during the murder of George Floyd and the protests that took place three years ago, many brands have been relatively quiet around Tyre Nichols.