Facebook ad exec’s Russia tweets show the perils of transparency
Facebook execs have been using Twitter as a bullhorn to get their point of view on Facebook’s myriad issues with publishers across — a strategy that has been blessed, if not guided, by Facebook public relations.
It’s also a strategy the platform giant may have been regretting since this weekend.
An indictment against 13 Russians by U.S. special counsel Robert Mueller found that Facebook had an integral role in how Russian agents were able to use fake news articles and ads spread on Facebook. In a series of tweets, Rob Goldman, Facebook’s vp of advertising, said that while he applauded Mueller’s indictments, he does not think Russia was trying to sway the 2016 presidential election. He also said the majority of Russians’ spending on Facebook ads happened after the election, and the goal for Russia was to actually divide America.
Most of the coverage of Russian meddling involves their attempt to effect the outcome of the 2016 US election. I have seen all of the Russian ads and I can say very definitively that swaying the election was *NOT* the main goal.
— Rob Goldman (@robjective) February 17, 2018
President Donald Trump then quoted Goldman’s tweet.
There’s been a firestorm of negativity since the tweets, which essentially are being lambasted for being, ironically, fake news. The New York Times and Quartz have both put out stories fact-checking Goldman’s assertions, while Jason Kint, head of Digital Content Next, a trade group representing digital publishers, told Goldman to “go away.”
Mainardo de Nardis, executive vice chairman at Omnicom Media Group and one of Facebook’s biggest ad buyers, tweeted that Goldman’s tweets have created “confusion and anger.” OMD declined to comment further.
You really are not in a position to preach and your astonishing tweets have created confusion and anger. Enough damage done over the past 2+ years. In the absence of real actions silence would be appreciated.
— Mainardo de Nardis (@mdenardis) February 18, 2018
Asked for comment, Joel Kaplan, Facebook’s vp of global policy, said in a statement: “Nothing we found contradicts the Special Counsel’s indictments. Any suggestion otherwise is wrong.” According to Axios, Facebook also made overtures in Washington to staffers on the Hill that essentially distanced its official policy from Goldman’s comments, showing it actually had been cooperating with Mueller and the FBI in both this case as well as about issues of abuse on Facebook.
Goldman’s tweets seemed to have been made in a personal capacity, and it’s clear that while Facebook has certainly been encouraging executives to use Twitter for a publisher charm offensive — and more — it doesn’t have a lot of control over what they actually say. A Facebook rep couldn’t comment further on whether the strategy has backfired or whether it’ll be reeled in.
After Recode editor Kara Swisher essentially told Goldman to stop tweeting, Facebook executive and head of consumer hardware Andrew Bosworth asked if Facebook should not be transparent about its findings, couching Goldman’s tweets as a way to bring transparency to what is happening at the company.
This is an interesting Kara. You prefer we not be transparent about our findings? Agreed the context that this was just related on ads on FB should have been provided, but surprised to hear you call for less transparency.
— Emotional Support Boz (@boztank) February 18, 2018
Over the last two weeks, Facebook executives, including product vp Adam Mosseri and product director Rob Leathern, have tweeted about algorithm changes, fake news and bad ads. It’s a looser approach to PR than Facebook has traditionally practiced; the PR team has been aware and encouraged the execs’ tweeting, but doesn’t ask them to run it by the in-house team. The Twitter actions had gone over pretty well earlier; most people saw this as a way to humanize a company beyond just making critiques about it. But now it’s unclear that they will.
A communications expert at a PR company that couldn’t speak on the record because it has clients that work with Facebook said he “wouldn’t be surprised” if Facebook started muzzling some of its executives, especially on Twitter, especially right now. “I don’t know if you want some keyboard-happy tweeters right now, when everything seems to be working against you in the court of public opinion.”
At agencies, furloughs are the new layoffs
Agency execs and experts believe that agencies are more inclined to use a furlough than a layoff if they have that option. Agencies are a people business and the need to retain top talent any way they can will likely encourage agencies to use furloughs when possible.
Member ExclusiveMall rats: Gen Z shoppers are rerouting the future of physical retail
As “retail apocalypse” rumors continue to fly, teenagers are reviving shopping centers’ foot traffic. Among the draws are a social experience, immediate gratification, a personal branding opportunity and a much-needed break from their mobile phones.
‘Everyone wants control’: Traffic soars, but programmatic ad prices drop
Since the onset of the global pandemic, advertisers have either paused or pulled media dollars, which has sent programmatic prices haywire. All of this has been driven by the uncertainty of what lies ahead.
SponsoredSurvey: The threats of deceptive ads in 2020
Publishers and advertisers: How are you planning to block, eliminate and avoid deceptive ads in 2020? How will deceptive ads impact the 2020 election? Are you seeing deceptive ads that exploit the coronavirus crisis? Take this short survey and we’ll provide the results.
‘More volatile than ever’: Freelancers brace for a rough job market
Due to the coronavirus, freelancers say the job market is much more competitive and that, overall, prospects are slim to none.
‘Your communities want to hear from you more than ever’: How SAP CMO Alicia Tillman is leading through the coronavirus crisis
SAP felt the hit of the coronavirus outbreak early on this year, canceling three of its own customer events and a large presence at SXSW on safety grounds. As the situation developed, SAP’s CMO Alicia Tillman instructed her team to reprioritize the media mix around digital and short-term activations that can help its corporate customers […]